News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by reustle on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:22PM (#16030520)
> An estimated $16 billion will be lost to ad fraud this year, and a significant portion of that will go to criminals who use bots and other nefarious means to siphon money out of the digital ad ecosystem.

That's a mind bogglingly big number, if true. I don't really find myself feeling sorry for advertisers, though.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by ghostbrainalpha on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:40PM (#16030639)
You shouldn't feel bad for the advertisers, but you should be worried about the content producers you love who provide you free content based on advertisements.

If true fraud levels were exposed it could shift the digital economy in a massive way.

Say you have an unpopular dishwasher and it breaks. It's great to go to Youtube and find someone showing you how to fix the problem even for a relatively niche dishwasher. But if the ad money dries up for that content producer, that video won't be there the next time you look for it.

Or you will be forced to pay $1.00 to watch it.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by userbinator on Friday December 29, 2017 @02:21PM (#16031331)
It's great to go to Youtube and find someone showing you how to fix the problem even for a relatively niche dishwasher. But if the ad money dries up for that content producer, that video won't be there the next time you look for it.

Not everyone who makes YouTube videos is doing it for ad money, especially the sort of content you're referring to. A lot of people just do it to document things for themselves and use YT as a "convenient place to put videos"; the fact that everyone else can see is incidental.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by chamakits on Friday December 29, 2017 @02:42PM (#16031467)
Very true.

But the only reason that YouTube is there as a platform that allows people to upload videos for free is that they expect to make money either off of that video through ads, or through other videos through ads.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by manmal on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:54PM (#16032870)
Not necessarily true. Some want to get famous with their videos, some want to express themselves in a creative way, or spread ideas, or build an online following to capitalize later on...
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by mikebenfield on Friday December 29, 2017 @11:33PM (#16033860)
I think the point is that Youtube expects to make money off that video. If Youtube could not make money from people's content, it wouldn't exist.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by nightcracker on Saturday December 30, 2017 @01:13AM (#16034106)
For a while now I've been thinking about the idea of having a state-funded free and open video and image sharing platform. In the modern world I view sites such as imgur and youtube as vital infrastructure, and would really like to see them removed from commercial influence.

Just like roads need to be created regardless of their profitability, I think it's important for society that we have means to share and view image and video content regardless of profitability.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by x0x0 on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:01PM (#16031608)
The vast majority are. Producing high quality content -- a good camera, good lighting, clear views into the disassembled appliances -- is a lot of work.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by matte_black on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:44PM (#16031855)
As technology improves though this is getting easier and easier.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by Sir_Substance on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:26PM (#16032097)
>You shouldn't feel bad for the advertisers, but you should be worried about the content producers you love who provide you free content based on advertisements.

You're getting paid with advertising dollars for posting on hacker news?

Surprise: you (and all the other posters on hacker news) are the content producers I love. We've never been paid for this nonsense, and I doubt we ever will be. Won't stop us posting though. I'm really not that worried if buzzfeed and medium go under.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by striking on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:59PM (#16030772)
I pay for YouTube Red. So that person could be making money and I'm not seeing ads.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:28PM (#16033231)
And? Worth it? I don't spend a lot of time on YT but sometimes I wonder how much I'd save in time, inconvenience and distractions if I did Red.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by striking on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:36PM (#16033271)
I use an adblocker for most sites, but I enjoy the fuzzy feelings Red gives me. Also, I get Google Play Music All Access, and adblocking doesn't work on mobile.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by bastawhiz on Saturday December 30, 2017 @12:15AM (#16033948)
I have it because I pay for Google Play Music. I don't know how people use YouTube without it. If I load a YouTube video in a private browsing window or on a friend's device, I can't imagine what it must be like watching all those ads.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by hateful on Saturday December 30, 2017 @11:44AM (#16035979)
I pay $15/mo for Google Play family. Even though I don't use the Music service, it comes with YouTube Red for you and 4 other family members.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by stetrain on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:40PM (#16031842)
It could cause short-term shocks, but I feel like over the long run things would recover.

If the advertisers thought they were paying $500 for 10000 clicks resulting in $1000 worth of visible revenue, the fact that they really only got 5000 "real" clicks resulting in the same $1000 worth of visible revenue doesn't really change the equation much.

Over the long run companies spending money on advertising are going to hone in on how much they can spend compared to how much revenue they get can trace back to that advertising spend.

The pay-per-click model and the current cost-per-click pricing is just an implementation detail of the current state of web advertising. Advertising still works when those stats aren't available, like in Podcasts.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by cujo on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:36PM (#16032160)
It does matter though. They don't say they want 10000 clicks in a vacuum. They pay for that many clicks because the math tells them it should be worth $1k in revenue. In reality someone is manipulating the math

They should have been able to dedicate half the money for the same revenue, or the same money for double the rev, in your scenario.

Put another way, the estimate is that they pay out $500 for $2k in revenue, then someone came in and dumped a bunch of bots in the way and ate away half their revenue. It's not like those empty clicks are people who just weren't compelled to buy what they were selling. They are bots intentionally disrupting commerce.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by tyingq on Friday December 29, 2017 @05:31PM (#16032483)
"Over the long run companies spending money on advertising are going to hone in on how much they can spend compared to how much revenue they get can trace back to that advertising spend."

In some niches, there's an unending new supply of get-rich-quick newbies that will pay for underperforming ads.

There's really no incentive for Google's AdSense team to focus on fraud in these spaces. Because the suckers just keep coming. Google profits from it, so there's little incentive to fix the glitch.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by fendmark on Saturday December 30, 2017 @12:34AM (#16034007)
Publishers are buying traffic that is too good to be true from dubious networks and then it is being laundered through the programmatic ad tech machine at scale.

Brands looking to build awareness are buying access to this fraudulent traffic.

Advertising agencies, ad tech companies, and publishers more times than not are incentivized to look the other way and not investigate what is going on too closely as long as it is profitable.

Digital display advertising has long been considered a channel of questionable effectiveness. But the current state of programmatic advertising has made things much worse and will ultimately lead to Advertisers pulling billions of dollars out of this space unless there are significant improvements in getting more transparency into their advertising investments.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by manmal on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:52PM (#16032864)
The typical dish washer repair video on YT with 10-100k views makes $10-100 in total. And many don’t even have ads enabled. So these are hardly going to be affected.

Now, I‘m not sure YouTube itself will survive in its current form if ad money dries up.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by QAPereo on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:21PM (#16032077)
That would lead to massive piracy... it is not a solution. A business model needs work like a business, not a charity, and you’re always competing its free.

It’s simple... ad value or die as a business. Is that easy? No, but why should it be?

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by dooglius on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:32PM (#16031790)
I'd be shocked if the ad revenue per video view were even a cent, and I'd happily pay a cent to see the video in the scenario you described.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by manmal on Friday December 29, 2017 @06:56PM (#16032882)
Indeed, content creators are often better off with a patreon account.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by ghostbrainalpha on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @01:12PM (#16053838)
You are right Patreon is great, but in the case I mentioned above, I would never support someone on Patreon after my specific dishwasher issue was fixed.

Patreon works great when you enjoy someone content on a continual basis. These 1 off trouble shooting type of content producers need to find their own way.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by LeifCarrotson on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:52PM (#16030725)
It's not that large a number. All of advertising is a $500-$800 billion business depending on where you get the numbers, so that represents 2.5% lost to fraud.

That is believable to me. Larger than fraud in a lot of markets, but not particularly large, and everyone knows the market is full of bots, bad stats, and scams.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by scott00 on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:19PM (#16030899)
A recent estimate of the digital ad market puts it at $105 billion[1]. Divide $16 billion by that and you get 15%.

[1] http://avc.com/2017/12/the-digital-advertising-duopoly/

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by tinymollusk on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:03PM (#16030798)
As someone who has run a lot of decent sized FB campaigns, the norm would be for me to receive about 60-70% of the clicks I paid for. Not saying that was all fraud, maybe some people clicked and changed their mind... but I suspect the real "fraud" number is much, much higher than 2.5%. My guess is around 25%.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by soared on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:35PM (#16031016)
Clicks aren't sessions so you can't compare them and claim most of the missing sessions are fraud.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by tinymollusk on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:21PM (#16031731)
I was matching my advertising reports with server logs, GA, and piwik. I wasn't trying to naively compare two different metrics.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by soared on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:16PM (#16033189)
Well still, even in a perfect set up something like 20% of your display clicks still won't be counted as sessions. Lots of misclicks, exits before analytics loads, etc.

Edit: Oh did you mean advertising reports for sessions?

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by tinymollusk on Saturday December 30, 2017 @05:18PM (#16037989)
I tried all kinds of things. The most interesting thing (to me) was the clicks_paid_for / clicks_landed changed, depending on different targeting mechanisms I used.

I may have forgotten to acknowledge that I never really cared I didn't get all the clicks -- I was doing a CPA campaign, so I just baked in the non-visits.

Depending on targeting and platform, there was almost always a 20-70% discrepancy between the clicks I paid for (reported by the ad platform), and the visits that landed on my site (reported by GA, server logs, piwik, and analytics.js).

Also interesting - AdWords was always within 5%.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by Feniks on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:17PM (#16030890)
You should feel sorry for yourself as a consumer. Were do you think advertising money comes from? At the end of the day its all priced in the product.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by imh on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:22PM (#16030920)
Is it? I don't mean that facetiously. If you and I are both selling the same product and you spend more on marketing, does that mean you can raise your price that much more, or is it just a little, where the primary spending comes at the expense of your margins?

I'm sure it differs case by case, but I would naively expect the latter is more common if you have competitors.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by philipodonnell on Friday December 29, 2017 @02:56PM (#16031579)
People in tech tend to look down on MBAs, but these are the kind of pricing decisions you learn how to make. It depends on your brand strategy, the strategies of competing brands, the anticipated lift, your margins, your assumptions about the margins of your competitors, the advertising channels available, your ability to enforce pricing discrimination (the innocous version), the macroeconomic environment... And on and on.

There's never a right answer to "am I charging the best price", it's always a guess.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by manmal on Friday December 29, 2017 @07:02PM (#16032904)
Sure, but are the MBAs really good at this, or are they not also just winging it, finding the right strategies via hit and miss? I don’t look down on them, but find them full of strange ideas and dogma that falls apart when tested in real world situations. (Just my n=1 observation, and I probably have it all wrong)
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by philipodonnell on Saturday December 30, 2017 @02:19PM (#16036906)
In any discrete instance it may seem like that, but what you interpret as "strange ideas and dogma that falls apart when tested in real world situations" to a practitioner is a history of different approaches to a problem that have been tried in the past, a few standard ones that are sort of your go-to, and a huge amount of case studies and research about why different approaches worked or not and what might make it work or not again in the future.

The problem always is that it very difficult for an observer to tell the difference between an educated guess and just a, like, regular guess. So I don't fault anyone for interpreting it like that.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by jstarfish on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:39PM (#16031832)
It depends on the industry.

When I was shopping for lawyers, not that it was a consideration in my evaluations but I found that lawyers I recognized from subway or daytime TV ads were considerably more expensive than random selections from the phonebook. Their ads project images where you've been victimized, and you need a legal gladiator, willing to fight the evil empire to get all that settlement money that rightfully belongs to you. I found that the service was better with the random selects-- free consultations, quicker responses to inquiries, more services rendered, better aftercare, etc.

Dentistry is the same. I've noticed a lot of billboards for dental services around my area. Most of them evoke Fisher-Price colors and softness, playing up to peoples' fears in how the experience doesn't have to be scary or painful. But when I did the legwork for quotes on significant dental work, I found that those that offices which advertised were much more expensive than random Yelp selections. The quotes varied by thousands of dollars for the same work.

Auto repair does things slightly differently. I live in a small town and don't have much choice in this space, but for lack of time I recently took a vehicle to a shop that bought ad placements simply because aside from that their reputation in town was better. Their quote was fair and accurate given the job and they did the work without playing any games or breaking anything else. But then they tried to upsell me on additional services (fluid changes, etc.) at absolutely obscene prices. Since auto ownership is a cargo cult where nobody knows even the basics of what goes into making them work, I'm sure this tactic works on plenty of other rubes.

Similar story-- I had a car break down on the side of the road on a long road trip. AAA towed it to the nearest repair shop, which happened to be a dealership (dealerships generally spend mad money on ads, and already have reputations for being overpriced). I know the failed part cost less than $300 and would take less than an hour to put in. They must have seen the out-of-state plates and the after-hours dropoff and banked on my presumed desperation and ignorance because their quote was $6000. I said no, had it towed to another garage and got it done for $450.

The presumption is that consumers don't (or in some cases, literally can't) shop around, are generally unintelligent and are easily swayed by appeals to emotion, so you play to these factors and charge as much as you can get away with-- not some paltry "(cost of goods + cost of labor + cost of advertising) + 10% markup" silliness.

My rule of thumb is that anything you see advertised is a sign of a hustle. If you don't know how the hustle works, you'll get got. This applies doubly so for anything marketed to the poor or minorities.

Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by nradov on Friday December 29, 2017 @07:32PM (#16033014)
That $16 billion figure is bullshit. Even if there was zero fraud most of that money would have been "lost" anyway.
Re:Publishers Bought Millions of Website Visits They Found O... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:26PM (#16033227)
And now...Take out the spam emails. Take out the porn. Geez, how much of the internet is mainstream legit?