Simpler than a water reservoir and regolith sandbags? The former is required anyways, since people will need water, and the later is about as simple as it comes (we use sandbags here on earth all the time for impromptu buildings).
Even just regolith sandbags are going to suck, instead of just having your roof be a simple pressure vessel it's now going to also have to withstand tons of sandbags and water tanks.
And that's before we get to the problem of trying to either ship all of this extra water mass over, or trying to mine it locally, or the construction logistics of piling up hundreds of tons of sand.
All of this will be needed eventually, but it's absurd that NASA is trying to get in the way of Mars colonization by setting these overly conservative safety requirements which'll significantly hinder initial colonization efforts.
Also - the simple designs have a problem here- they are not easily repairable with local materials. And as you can see on any airplane- those simple soda can designs- wear out pretty fast, if pressure changes regularly. So, yeah- its a simpler design as in - simpler on earth to maintain, but on Mars its going to blow up like Mark Rodneys Potatoefarm from stress around the airlocks.
The process of colonizing Mars should be that we realistically look at how much payload we can send up there, how much it costs, and then we find some adventurers willing to take risks to go.
I don't think it's unrealistic to say as a first approximation that the first people to land on Mars can expect a 10% chance of dying by just trying to get there, and 30% of dying early due to some complications, e.g. radiation exposure.
Those would have been fantastic odds when the New World was first colonized, or when soldiers landed on Omaha beach. Colonizing Mars needs to be looked at like that, not in terms of sending some government employee into a dangerous situation, as if though they're going to repair some machinery here on Earth.
Instead, NASA views their rules on safety as immutable, and is coming up with designs for habitats and ships to satisfy those rules, without ever having the discussion that perhaps those rules are unreasonable given the endeavour.
> Within the root network, residents will have
> their private spaces protected from harsh
> radiation, meteoroid impact, and thermal
> environment.
> [...]
> The radiation protection will be enhanced by
> the inclusion of a layer in the shield
> consisting of a water reservoir.
> [...]
> This [regolith layer] layer can also serve
> as shielding from solar and cosmic radiation
> fields. The thickness of the layer would be
> variable, with thicker construction in the
> directions with greater sun exposure.
> [...]
> The weight of the regolith sandbags will
> provide protection from radiation and
> impact;
If they're not worried about radiation why would they construct walls
that are thicker on the side that faces the sun?I bet there'd be a lot of people with short life expectancies who'd want to spend what they have left embarking on the greatest adventure in history.
For the smokers sent to Mars living in flimsy shelters this'll decrease their lifetime odds of dying from cancer compared to smoking two packs a day and staying on Earth.
This article like so many others describes designs for Mars habitats that are optimized for being accepted under NASA's strict safety rules, and it's an organization run by safety-obsessed bureaucrats.
I predict that once the second space race kicks off in earnest these unpractical restrictions are going to be quickly dismissed, because NASA's going to have to compete with e.g. China which'll likely use much simpler designs because they're realistic about their risk assessments.
1. https://www.space.com/21813-mars-one-colony-space-radiation....