News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by hliyan on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:29AM (#16021313)
That's really not the author's point. I think this quote illustrates his point better:

"Online shopping came along in the 1990s but retailers struggled to adapt business processes to the internet. They needed to build complementary infrastructure such as fulfillment centers, and, the authors note, customers had to adapt their habits, as well."

The lag between commercialization and widespread adoption is wider than we think.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by lucidguppy on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:20AM (#16021638)
If Sears and Service Merchandise had simply held out for a couple of years and put up a web store front - the Dow would look a little different today.

Customers had adapted in the late 80's to something like Amazon (only problem was waiting for a few minutes after checkout) - but then they adapted to big box stores (made possible by big banks and supply chain software) - which ended up being a huge diversion of resources in the late 90's early 00's. The empty husks of retail are a testament to that.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by sixtypoundhound on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:17AM (#16022381)
Hmm... that presumes sears (the organization) can change fast enough to identify and embrace the right business model. There's more than a website to running a successful e-commerce business.

Internal culture at Google / Amazon, especially during the growth phase, was likely very different than your typical Fortune 500.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by DrScump on Thursday December 28, 2017 @11:25PM (#16027515)
It's not clear to me why Service Merchandise (and its predecessors like Best Products, Consumers Distributing, and Unity Buying Service) all failed back then. They certainly couldn't compete now with the economies of scale of Walmart or Amazon.

It's odd that online grocery shopping is so huge now given Webvan's crash and burn in that space not all that long ago.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by heisenbergs on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:56AM (#16021391)
Lag is probably the wrong word. It's a misconception that adoption should be instant. It took a good 50 years for the electric motor to supplant the steam engine, despite it being superior in virtually every way. Tech adoption takes time, given that many things need to be re-learnt/engineered.

It's why i'm positive that there won't be swathes of unemployeed people due to tech. It will happen gradually, as it has always been, and people will have to be shifted into different and more productive employment types. It has always happened this way, and will likely continue to do so.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by marcosdumay on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:07AM (#16022334)
As long as there are more productive employment types available.

Anyway, I disagree. I think the sheer speed of the change will create a disaster much sooner than automation quality will make humans obsolete. It took more than a century for the steam engine to replace animal engines around the world, then the electric engine replaced it in half a century. Things are accelerating, and are already much faster than by that time.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by Chathamization on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:54AM (#16022673)
Productivity growth has actually been relatively low recently[1]. There doesn't seem to be a trend towards acceleration.

[1] https://www.bls.gov/lpc/prodybar.htm

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by hateduser2 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:16AM (#16021623)
I don’t think “it’s always happened this way so it probably will continue “ (although you explain this further) is a very sophisticated or for that matter accurate analysis. There’s the status quo and then there are major events that upend it. If anything could ever upend the status who like this, it’s tech. It’s like business cycles.. usually things are fine but they aren’t always fine.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by starlust2 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:27AM (#16021657)
Converting a user operated machine from a steam engine to electric engine doesn't remove the user. Converting to a computer operated or assisted machine does.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by icebraining on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:42AM (#16021709)
If the electric engine can produce the same things ten times faster, you've just removed nine-tenths of the users. Sure, someone is still around, but then again, automatic factories still have some people supervising them - just much fewer.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by mjburgess on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:54AM (#16021973)
Increasing worker productivity has always lead to fulfilling larger a demand.

What is missing from all these discussions is that human wanting is essential infinite. The more productive you can be at making something, the more it will be taken for granted and a new thing wanted.

Demand is infinite. Work is created to supply it. There is no amount of labour that will ever exhaust it.

All automation does is increase the space of "taken for granted products". The infinite space of potential products/services for human beings to supply still exists.

80% of the UK economy is already services from people to other people.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by djrobstep on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:10AM (#16022348)
This ignores diminishing returns of additional labour and consumption.

If we reach the happy situation where robots are providing us with the things we need for a good life almost automatically, why would we continue to work ourselves to the bone for additional goods and services that won't increase our happiness much? Most people would rather just work less.

In fact, our current level of economic output is enough to give every household a comfortable life, even if we worked substantially less.

Unfortunately the system is structured to maximize labour time, keep us economically insecure, and use us all as grist for the capitalist mill, rather than maximizing leisure time and quality of life.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by Eridrus on Thursday December 28, 2017 @12:01PM (#16023226)
There is a fundamental competition baked into existence in the form of land rights and human attention. Who gets to live where? Who are your friends? Who gets to go to that fancy college? While there are other ways of answering this question than "those who can afford it", it will always exist in some form.

While automation of necessities will make it easier to opt out of the capitalist mill, I would expect that to not be a tradeoff-free choice.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by yorwba on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:27AM (#16022452)
Demand is ultimately limited by human attention. There is only so much time someone can spend buying goods and services, especially if they intend to actually do something with them. And the demand for each individual product is far below that. There are some products virtually everyone will buy, but usually only once in a certain timeframe. Then there are specialized things like combines or milling machines where demand only goes up if some other industry expands.

If you improve your factory equipment to produce double the items per employee-hour at a lower unit cost, you likely won't see the demand double in proportion. Most likely you'll just eat into the market share of a competitor. Maybe some new customers will newly be able to afford the product, but once it has "taken for granted" status, even that is impossible.

And we are not increasing the number of these "taken for granted products" very quickly. As far as physical products are concerned, I can only think of the smart phone as a recent example; actually that decreased the number of those products, by obsoleting cameras and dumb phones for most people. Among internet services, advertising is the dominant money-maker, and that's a zero-sum game for eyeballs which only employs a relatively small number of people.

As more and more products and services are provided by machines, fewer and fewer people become necessary to keep things running in the background. Sure, some of the replaced people can try to come up with new things to offer, but most of them won't succeed, and the vast majority will eventually be unable to cost-effectively provide value to other humans at all.

At that point, we'll find out whether it's cheaper to feed them or shoot them.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by toastermoster on Friday December 29, 2017 @12:43AM (#16027833)
You make some very solid points. However, most of the civilian guns are owned by people that most here would likely associate with being unable to cost-effectively provide any value to other humans at some point in the future. A large portion of those who are in the military associate with such people. Who is going to be performing said shooting? Just a thought.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by icebraining on Friday December 29, 2017 @05:04AM (#16028669)
Who is going to be performing said shooting?

Drones, of course.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by smaddox on Thursday December 28, 2017 @09:28AM (#16022140)
Human wanting and economic demand are not identical. In order for human wanting to turn into economic demand, those who want need to have money (in a capitalistic society). If there are limited numbers of jobs and limited forms of need/want-based income redistribution, then demand is limited.
Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by wott on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:12PM (#16026345)
I completely disagree.

It has been a while that demand stalls. We can see it by observing that energy (time, investment, ...) doesn't go much any more to production means, but to advertisement, marketing, new forms of distribution, and so on. Production is enough in many domains (and there is no room for newcomers, it contracts rather than develops, you just compete to take shares from someone else, not that much to contribute to a booming market), the current problem and aim of companies are to invent ways to get people to consume more and more stuff.

Re:A Tech-Driven Boom Is Coming; Please Be Patient by methodin on Thursday December 28, 2017 @11:33AM (#16023045)
It seems the world today the timing is entirely based on the country. In the U.S. the time it took for regular mobile phones to be supplanted by smartphones is ridiculously small yet the same cannot be said for many countries in the world. It seems to me that countries slow to make progress in tech will be the victims of it initially. It won't take that long to do so once the economic and logistical aspects of are ironclad.