News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by aphextron on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:57AM (#16015993)
As someone completerly uninvested in this whole mania, I still see Bitcoin as something with an inherent value. The real problem right now is that nobody knows what that inherent value really is. Even if the price were to crash 100x tomorrow, Bitcoin would still have some value because of the energy expenditure involved with Proof of Work. Of course people that are "investing" in it now are simply gambling. But Bitcoin itself will pretty much always have some worth because it will be impossible to recreate the amount of effort that went into mining it.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by aetherson on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:08PM (#16016090)
No, that's a fundamental misunderstanding of what value is. And a manifestation of a common one!

Things don't have value because of how much it cost to create them. They have value because of how much people are willing to buy them for.

If you and I both produce spoons, and the spoons that we produce are identical in every way, but I have a more efficient manufacturing process and it costs me less to produce those spoons, that does not make your spoons worth "more." And, importantly for people who are drawn to this idea, we should not attempt to legislate that your spoons are worth "more" for fairness reasons -- this fundamental approach to value is exactly what creates incentives for me to find efficiencies in manufacturing.

Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by aphextron on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:22PM (#16016248)
The point I'm making is that it would still have value as a currency, regardless of whatever the face price of USD value crashes to. It's something that cannot be reproduced and is easily tradeable.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by aetherson on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:21PM (#16017184)
Huh, okay, misunderstood you. That's a fair point.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:02PM (#16016036)
So there is inherent value in burning piles of cash, because 'cash went into creating it'? I don't get the logic.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by hannasanarion on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:11PM (#16016125)
Yeah, that's like saying that a pound of shredded bills has value. Like, yeah, you can trade it, and yeah, value was spent to create it, but you can't get that back.

It's not like buying bitcoin gives you back electricity.

Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by empraptor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:25PM (#16017218)
Interesting off-topic tidbit that is not meant to derail your point:

You could probably send the shredded bills to a US department that examines mutilated cash and get compensated.

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/06/30/.../episode-78... https://www.moneytips.com/mutilated-currency-101

Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by rlefebvre on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:29PM (#16016308)
It is the scarcity that creates the 'value'. Unless everybody walks away from the idea that it is worth something (may happen), then its value is still driven by how difficult it is to create some.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by root_axis on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:45PM (#16016431)
Scarcity doesn't create value. A copy of my personal memoir is extremely scarce, yet the value is zero. Further, bitcoin only has the illusion of scarcity, and clearly that's enough, but as was demonstrated by BCH, the supply of coins can be trivially increased. Enthusiasts will argue "BCH is not BTC, they're two separate currencies", but this is missing the point that "crypo-tokens" are an unlimited resource that is artificially limited through a consensus that can change at any time.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by UncleMeat on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @05:19PM (#16018542)
The total volume of my excrement over the course of my lifetime is scarce. Yet it is worthless to investors. Scarcity alone does not make something valuable.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by rlefebvre on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:04AM (#16022319)
I understand that you consider bitcoin to be sht and do not want it. It seems enough people have confidence in its mechanisms though. So that would be scarcity+confidence that gives it its value. But the same thing happens with the next crypto currency (your neighbors' sht) so maybe it is worth nothing after all. Not taking a stance, just trying to understand.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by nwah1 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:04PM (#16016052)
The fact that energy was expended doing all the hashing does not mean that the "coins" have value. It is entirely possible to expend energy on useless activity, thereby converting valuable electricity into useless waste.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:09PM (#16016109)
Energy expenditure alone cannot guarantee value. I can think of plenty of ways I could expend huge amounts of energy that wouldn't create value.
Re:Warren Buffett: Bitcoin Is Pure FOMO by kesor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:11PM (#16016134)
There is a known name for this, it is called "Sunk Cost". If it cost you a billion dollars to build a spaceship that doesn't fly, that spaceship is not worth a billion dollars - it is worth nothing. Capish?