News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hockney–Falco thesis by YeGoblynQueenne on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @08:12PM (#16012116)
This is an interesting idea, but it's impossible to know for sure if it's true or not. It's unfalsifiable, basically.

The reason -and it's a technical, not a philosophical reason- is that theories like this are really trying to determine a process from examples of its output, where the output in this case is some behaviour of a living organism (a human artist creating a painting). Unfortunately, for a sufficiently complex behaviour there may be any number of processes capable of reproducing it to the same degree of fidelity- "any number" as in an infinite many [1].

The best you can hope to do then, is to approximate the target process to some arbitrary measure of error. You can easily measure the error by comparing examples of the target process with examples of an approximator. However, you cannot prove that an approximator _is_ the target process- not even given 0 error in the reproduction, because finding one approximator is more of a hint that there are more approximators possible than any sort of proof that the approximator you found is the only process capable of reproducing those examples with that error.

So the problem with the Hockney-Falco idea is that there is no way to tell whether a work of art was created using an optical device, rather than without. Only that it could have. And that's really the strongest claim that one can legitimately make: "the Old Masters could have used optical devices to create their masterpieces". From there to "... and they actually did" is a big leap- of faith, not reason.

____________________

[1] There's maths on that- learnability results, particularly related to automata induction and so on. I'll dig out the refs if anyone is curious. But oh god, please don't :)

Re:Hockney–Falco thesis by tfha on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @08:52PM (#16012282)
Well, you could prove it by digging up texts and commentaries from the time that mention these devices. Diary entries, etc.

It's unlikely that so many masters would use this technique without leaving some evidence of it behind. So, in the absence of that kind of evidence, I think it'd be okay to dismiss it as a primary force of innovation during the renaissance, especially if other techniques exist that were more readily discussed.