News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @11:15AM (#1601119)
I run the Cool Calvin and Hobbes Collection - http://calvinandhobbes.me - and as one of the very early fan sites have seen many C&H fan sites come and go.

For most of the past 15 years, the most popular C&H site was Martijn Reemst's site which was truly comprehensive. Sadly that was taken down a few years ago because it featured a search engine. The same thing happened to S. Anand's fan site once they offered a search engine as well.

From what I have observed, in the late 90's Universal Press Syndicate was quite aggressive in pursuing C&H fan sites and getting them shutdown. However from 2000 onwards, they have taken a much more relaxed (enlightened?) approach with few C&H fan sites being pursued for copyright infringement. In fact, the only sites that I know that have been shutdown are those that have run search engines.

I've long been tempted to add such a search engine to my site as I've already got it all coded up and indexed already, but I'm quite fond of my site since it was the first website I ever created (and what started me on my IT career) and so don't want it shutdown.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by jparise on Friday August 13, 2010 @12:51PM (#1601420)
It looks like he already received a cease and desist request:

  Someone at AMU got in touch with me; a C&D was (is?)
  headed my way, but they seem open to finding a better
  solution, which is AWESOME. You may see some changes here
  in the next few days/week, but hopefully it will be in the
  best interest of everyone!
(Click the "A note from Michael, the creator" link on the site to read the full text.)
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @02:06PM (#1601685)
I also just noticed that Marcello's site is now unavailable. Marcello had downloaded the entire collection of Calvin and Hobbes comic strips from the gocomic site and made it available for download on his site. I've been surprised that it's lasted for so many months without any C&D notices being sent.

However, Michaels' search engine mentions Marcello's website as the source of the images and it looks like that has drawn the attention of the AMU lawyers (unless it's simply overloaded from demand).

I wouldn't be surprised if the script on scribd is taken down soon either.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by 1amzave on Friday August 13, 2010 @12:10PM (#1601295)
Hmm...could you sidestep that by just OCRing (or however) the text from the strips and putting it on the page, thereby allowing Google to index it and thus make it searchable? Or would they not allow that either?
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @12:16PM (#1601315)
Yup. I've actually been quite fascinated about the different ways to build my own C&H search engine and have implemented (but not publicly) it two ways - one of which was to do it the way you suggested.

I think from a 'will the publisher still it as copyright infringement' point of view, I think the answer is still yes if I host the text on my site. And so I haven't implemented my efforts as a result.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by mbreese on Friday August 13, 2010 @03:25PM (#1601967)
Usually this can be gotten around if you index the text, but don't display the text. This way you can still offer a search engine but not "publish" the text.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by dermatthias on Friday August 13, 2010 @04:39AM (#1600406)
There used to be another search engine by S. Anand, but it was taken down because of copyright bullshit (http://www.s-anand.net/calvinandhobbes.html). Wonder what will happen with this one...
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by vijaydev on Friday August 13, 2010 @07:45AM (#1600668)
Here's his post about taking down the site: http://www.s-anand.net/blog/the-calvin-and-hobbes-search-tak...
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by ed on Friday August 13, 2010 @07:27AM (#1600639)
Neat. An empty query brings up every strip:

http://michaelyingling.com/random/calvin_and_hobbes/search.p...

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by edkennedy on Friday August 13, 2010 @02:32PM (#1601784)
Your comment certainly contributed to bringing down the hosting.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by ed on Friday August 13, 2010 @02:50PM (#1601846)
Shrug. I think bad code had more to do with it.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by EvanK on Friday August 13, 2010 @11:24AM (#1601148)
This would be awesome if the website hosting the strips was actually up. Poor little sad broken image icons...
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by otherdave on Friday August 13, 2010 @10:19AM (#1600950)
Wow, great idea with the Search engine. Hopefully it can stay around for a while.

I've got a C & H fan site up at http://dontknockmysmock.com. It gets pretty low traffic and so far I haven't gotten any notice to take it down.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by quinndupont on Friday August 13, 2010 @09:50AM (#1600880)
I love Calvin and Hobbes but Watterson famously does not like these sorts of derivative works. Still, awesome service.

Service appears to be struggling to stay up.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @11:25AM (#1601149)
Bill Watterson objected to derivative works - ie C&H baseball caps, cartoons, fridge magnets, bumper stickers, colouring in books etc.

A search engine isn't a derivative work (at least in the way that Watterson dislikes). The objections to the search engines come from the publisher under the guise of copyright infringement. I would assume that whilst they can turn a blind eye to a fan site with the occasional infringing comic strips, they can't turn a blind eye to a search engine which contains the entire script of C&H.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by docgnome on Friday August 13, 2010 @04:09PM (#1602115)
If that is so then what is with all the urinating Calvin stickers? Every time I see one I feel like my childhood is being wizzed on.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Saturday August 14, 2010 @12:39AM (#1602957)
Those stickers are derivative work - unsanctioned and thoroughly frowned upon derivative work.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by jasonkester on Friday August 13, 2010 @03:48AM (#1600346)
Nice. I did a quick search for my favorite strip and it came up as the first result:

http://michaelyingling.com/random/calvin_and_hobbes/search.p...

There's lots of quotable stuff in the Calvin & Hobbes universe. Nice to see there's finally a way to find it.

Need one of these for Bloom County next.

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by makmanalp on Friday August 13, 2010 @01:50PM (#1601621)
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by thehigherlife on Friday August 13, 2010 @12:05PM (#1601282)
i have that exact comic posted on my cube wall.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by samratjp on Friday August 13, 2010 @09:26AM (#1600826)
I like how the search engine made by Bing :)

(Click on Why? to find out)

Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by bakhlawa on Friday August 13, 2010 @12:55PM (#1601428)
Might just be me, but in IE I get an auth login that never goes away...had to go through Task Manager to kill the browser.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by gacba on Friday August 13, 2010 @10:38AM (#1601009)
Can't be the REAL C&H search engine: I tried typing in "Bill Watterson" in the box and got NO search results. Seriously? If there's one query to get right, it's that one.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @11:16AM (#1601121)
Not really - the search engine is to search the Calvin and Hobbes comic strips. The strips never make any mention of Bill Watterson, so the fact you got zero results is completely accurate.
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by PidGin128 on Friday August 13, 2010 @02:42PM (#1601823)
To split hairs, I imagine his signature could be found in most of the comics...
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by tobtoh on Friday August 13, 2010 @03:09PM (#1601915)
To split it even further, he only signed his strips as 'Watterson' and so a search for 'Bill Watterson' or 'Bill AND Watterson' should return zero results :P
Re:Calvin & Hobbes Search Engine by ritonlajoie on Friday August 13, 2010 @02:43PM (#1601825)
about the fansites and the copyright, why don't the webmasters do that on stuff like onioncat ?