News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by viclou on Sunday December 24, 2017 @03:29PM (#16001180)
How does being rude with personal attacks help your case at all? (On a purely emotional level, it even makes me want to side with Uber for this)

> Oh my God. Are you seriously the Program Manager for Uber's Security Division, with a 2013 psych degree and zero relevant industry experience other than technical recruiting? LULZ (https://hackerone.com/reports/293359#activity-2203160)

> Cute. Big surprise. (https://hackerone.com/reports/293358#activity-2214673)

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by thisisit on Sunday December 24, 2017 @03:38PM (#16001209)
not to mention linking someone's social profile in a blog post about a company:

> So these tickets get assigned to Rob Fletcher with Uber’s security team.

Unfortunately, at least for me, this comes off as public shaming.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by thriftwy on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:54PM (#16001483)
Are you familiar with the freelancers' concept of "fuck you, pay me"?

I guess, that's how the first part works. There are things you can try, and there are other things. Messing with freelance pen testers is clearly one of latter.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by jacquesm on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:18PM (#16001599)
Given the nature of the game I'd say that's a mild response. On a scale of 0 to 10 that would rate a 3 or so. If there is one group I'd really avoid pissing off it would be pentesters.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by jwildeboer on Monday December 25, 2017 @02:41PM (#16005414)
The freelancers „fuck you, pay me“ is based on very clear contracts and respectful communication, even when things go bad. This is not what’s happening here AFAICS.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by thriftwy on Monday December 25, 2017 @05:04PM (#16005920)
"Minimum payout of $500" sounds like a very clear contract.

Once they have shadowbanned the author, IMO, any attempt at respectfulness is violated by bug bounty organizers.

Maybe there are things more rude than shadowban, but I'm not aware of such.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by jxf on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @12:40AM (#16007312)
The minimum payout is subject to various conditions — for example, not being a duplicate. The author did not meet those conditions, and resorted to personal attacks instead of keeping things professional.

Uber has many, many problems as a company, but on this matter I can't say they're in the wrong.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by thriftwy on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:30AM (#16007882)
Well, it doesn't seem like the last report was a duplicate.

The one they failed to recognize as XSS. If they paid for that one there would be no blog post and no name calling.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by itsdrewmiller on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:07PM (#16001302)
Clearly doesn't help his case, but it's not really material to whether they should pay out or not. Why didn't they disclose the one that most everyone here agrees was an obviously-qualified-for-payout vulnerability?
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by EnFinlay on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:21PM (#16001352)
It looks like a "reap what you sow" situation. No one is looking good now.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by wpietri on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:13PM (#16001577)
Uber is the last company in the world that gets to complain that somebody isn't being nice to them.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by jstandard on Monday December 25, 2017 @12:02PM (#16004806)
This seems unnecessarily callous. The writer was incredibly insulting to a person in a public forum, but that's ok because "well they worked for Uber"?

I don't see this discussion as about whether a corporate PR team is allowed to issue a response. It's about the author childishly lashing out at an individual because he didn't agree with their decision.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by wpietri on Monday December 25, 2017 @05:24PM (#16005981)
I didn't say it's ok. I said Uber doesn't get to complain.

Indeed, my belief is that this guy's and Uber's behavior are both not-ok, which is exactly why Uber doesn't get to complain.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by village-idiot on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @02:05PM (#16010263)
That's not how that works at all.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by chris_wot on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:32PM (#16001392)
Irrelevant. If he found these bugs, even if he’s been a dick about it then he still found a bunch of vulnerabilities that Uber was exposed to. Pay the man, it’s a few thousand dollars as opposed to a major exploit!
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by EnFinlay on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:42PM (#16001703)
But that's my point. Of course he deserved a payout if he reported a previously unknown vulnerability. What I'm saying is that he (appears to have) behaved in such toxic way (sow) that someone denied something he deserved (reap). All parties in this are squishy humans with emotions.

No one looks good - he doesn't look good for how he behaved/communicationed, Uber doesn't look good for denying the payout on a valid report, and Hackerone doesn't look good for not enforcing a minimum payout on a valid report.

Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by lordlimecat on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @12:02AM (#16007168)
Just because you violate social mores does not entitle someone to violate the terms of their engagement with you.
Re:I Got Paid $0 from the Uber Security Bug Bounty by sxcurity on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:52PM (#16001730)
A bunch of P5's that were rightly closed as informative. I completely agree w/ Uber's decisions here...