News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam by Retric on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:15PM (#16000850)
Physics is unbounded; it has infinite complexity at the extreme. Medicine is vastly more complex than say CPU design, but it still operates on well understood chemistry.
Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam by TeMPOraL on Sunday December 24, 2017 @03:16PM (#16001136)
And in XXX century it might flip the difficulty of the disciplines around. As it is right now, physics is dealing with relatively simple systems compared to medicine, which deals with absurdly complex systems.

Since you bring up CPU design, the appropriate comparison would be that medicine is to chemistry what CPU design is to physics, if by "CPU design" we mean reverse-engineering alien technology that operates on the edge of our understanding of physics and way beyond our ability to manipulate the physical world.

Medicine is practical and accepts not understanding the details because it has no other choice. In that regard, it's similar to social studies because the latter can't get into details without fully reverse-engineering a human brain either.

Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam by geezerjay on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:55AM (#16021037)
> Medicine is vastly more complex than say CPU design, but it still operates on well understood chemistry.

I'm not sure a researcher enjoys the same freedom to put together medical experiments as physicists and chemists do.

Moreover you comment sounds very disingenuous. It's like claiming that electronics is a realtively simple research domain because it still operates on well understood electromagnetics.

Meanwhile do keep in perspective that even today's state of the art in medicine involves various forms of mutilation.

Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam by Retric on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:41AM (#16029416)
Medicine can do just about anything with small clusters of cells and nobody would complain. That's not everything, but it is quite a bit.

Consider we generally do blood not lymph tests. That's a mix of practicality and tradition, but one one of many areas of basic research mostly left alone. Sure, doctors physically examine for enlarged lymph nodes, but that's because the immune system is largely based around the lymphatic system because that's mostly how diseases move around the body not through the blood.

Getting back to what I said, we can do a lot of high quality medical research that may or may not be useful in the long term, but we don't approach it as a research problem we approach it as an engineering problem looking for solutions to real world problems.

PS: As to CPU vs Medicine vs Physics. We are comparing numbers do large it's hardly meaningful, 10^20 (CPU) vs 10^30 (Medicine) vs infinity (Physics) all round to bigger than you can comprehend.