Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam
by mathattack on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:09PM
(#16000820)
High certainty but that comes with second order issues: many ideas are untested, and the ideas that are turn into papers with 100s of authors. This stifles independent thinking.
Re:Academic success is either a crapshoot or a scam
by whatshisface on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:19PM
(#16000874)
Here's a modern experimental paper. Scroll down to the authors. You'll know it when you see it.
https://cds.cern.ch/record/2282544/files/arXiv:1709.05260.pd...
Your statement about huge numbers of authors (as well as the great number of theoretical papers that have to wait a very long time before being confirmed or denied) is true.
Physicsts absolutely could be performing experiments with poorer statistics; it'd be cheaper, more advanced things would be done sooner, and we'd be having a replication crisis.
If the social sciences were willing to go a century without discovering anything exciting, they could achieve whatever level of certianty they wanted on their current budget. (At the expense of new discoveries.)