News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by provost on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:04PM (#15995985)
Hopefully this thread will be different than all the others. Someone is likely to appear here with a counterargument, which I'm looking forward to reading.

However, in addition to any counterarguments, please describe why standard tech and/or a 3rd_party is insufficient for your proposed use-cases. This is HackerNews after all, and we desire the deeply technical discussion and context, not propaganda.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by wallacoloo on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:35PM (#15996632)
It's hard to write a good counterargument to this. The article goes in so many directions that it could never cover all his points.

Any counterargument I can construct boils down to a difference of opinion & values. The author trusts his bank and his government to (a) handle his money in the way that he thinks is responsible and (b) handle disputes in a way that benefits him. On the other hand, I trust myself to handle my money responsibly, and I view my government as a great uncertainty because I don't understand the limits of their power (in the least nefarious, but relevant point, who can predict by how much my government will increase the monetary supply and deflate my purchasing power over the next decades? More nefarious, if I dissent, government can trivially lock most of my digital assets that aren't cryptocurrencies - e.g. bank account or investment funds).

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dorgo on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:09AM (#15998726)
The ability of the government to freeze your bank account is based (to some degree) on a consensus (or at least tolerance) of the people in the country that the government should have these powers.

Same is true for crypte-currencies. If some hacker manages to steal a big amount of money then (almost) everybody agrees to make a hardfork and the hacker looses his money. It is more decentralized and the hacker could keep some part of the money if there is a side chain.

Hacker scenario already happend. But there is no need for a crime to happen to cause a tokens redistribution. If 80% of all token holders (miners for bitcoin?) are poor what stops them from redistributing the tokens of the rich token holders?

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by richardwhiuk on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:41PM (#15996669)
Sure they can - put you in prison with no internet access.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by wallacoloo on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:56PM (#15996761)
Sure, but there are plenty of dissenters that manage to escape being in the physical custody of their government. One might reasonably decide to leave the country before dissenting, in some scenarios.

You can bet that Edward Snowden had all his US assets seized, for example. But if he had any cryptocurrency, he may have been able to take those with him.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by mrep on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:17PM (#15997338)
So, for Illegal activity? The article has already consented that illegal markets are 1 of the 2 current use cases. Got any others?
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by wallacoloo on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:45PM (#15997809)
> So, for Illegal activity

Say I'm someone like Ed Snowden (again). I own a house, a car, the clothes on my back, and Bitcoin. I up and leave one day to share government secrets with the press and hide in a different country.

Did the car aid in the crime? Probably, to some degree - it let me physically make my way to the airport, and on to journalists to whom I shared secrets. Did the house aid the crime? Did the clothes on my back aid the crime? Both of those allowed me to live a safe and comfortable life. I wouldn't have made it past airport security without my clothes, after all.

Did the Bitcoin aid the crime? Only in the same sense that a treadmill and a good diet aids a bank robber by making it easier for him to leave the scene in a hurry.

So I think the claim that having bitcoin in your possession when committing a crime necessarily enables that crime (to a greater deal than any other everyday thing) is a bit nebulous. It didn't facilitate the crime, it just lessened the punishment. Possession of $USD cash provides a similar thing in the form of being used to pay bail.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by josu on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:48AM (#15998361)
Jews escaping from Nazi Germany, Syrian refugees, Venezuela, Argentina, or every other Latin American country...
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dreit1 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:20PM (#15996072)
I know this isn't an answer that you will like....but blockchain allows me to invest in high risk investments that would typically only be allowed for accredited investors. Having the shares/coins in a blockchain provides for transparency and authenticity and makes legit companies act in a way that is generally favorable for the small time investor
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by bob2001 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:31PM (#15996614)
Can you explain how having shares/coins in the blockchain increases transparency/authenticity? Easily audit-able records would exist just the same if you bought your shares via wire transfer.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dreit1 on Sunday December 24, 2017 @10:20AM (#15999865)
So imagine an ICO company that has a premine. You know the address of all their funds that they raised, and you know all the funds that are held through their premine. You can easily track the money to make sure nothing fishy is going on. This isn't that big of a deal for a tiny company, but imagine this for a huge corporation or government body.

All of them CAN produce auditable records for the consumer, but they don't, blockchains force the issue.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by chadcmulligan on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:41PM (#15996671)
but isn't that just taking advantage of a (temporary) loop hole? The real problem there imho is that for some reason the government has decided that oh we need to step in and protect the unwise. Strangely this is by the same people that say government shouldn't be involved in the financial markets. There is no guarantee that having an ICO makes the investment any more bullet proof.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dreit1 on Sunday December 24, 2017 @10:22AM (#15999876)
Entire industries can be built on regulatory loopholes, Uber and Lyft come to mind.

Cryptocurrencies are forcing govts to reexamine regulations that I argue are generally favorable to massive institutions/ high net worth individuals and unfavorable to the small timers

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by adventured on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:10PM (#15997306)
> There is no guarantee that having an ICO makes the investment any more bullet proof.

Right now it's the exact opposite. There's nothing less bullet-proof (eg in the US) than investing into an ICO, outside of perhaps junk penny stocks.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by Daishiman on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:57PM (#15996221)
Which investments?
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dreit1 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:03PM (#15996245)
I'm into mainly into stuff that either pays or plans to pay dividends, NEO, WTC, ARK, ETH etc.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by zacurry on Monday December 25, 2017 @10:09AM (#16004337)
Off topic - I keep hearing that WTC (Walton) is a scam . How confident are u about it ?
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dreit1 on Monday December 25, 2017 @04:51PM (#16005872)
It is 100% not a scam. You can watch some videos where a youtube visits the office and talks to the team here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzhXncTVOzA

Whether or not it will be a successful project or not is up for debate.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by kemonocode on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:54PM (#15996205)
How would you expect someone in a third-world country to keep money away from a hyperinflating currency, without access to international banking? And no, we-will-suspend-your-account-if-you-look-at-us-funny PayPal is not an option. Cash in foreign currencies is extremely risky.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by root_axis on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:56PM (#15996465)
The people who are so poor that they don't have reliable access to banking services very often are lacking reliable access to internet connected computing devices and sometimes even electricity. Additionally, trading cryptocurrency for spendable money is time consuming and expensive. The idea that cryptocurrency is a viable option for the participants of third-world economies is absurd. I'm not saying that nobody in the third-world uses cryptotokens but its very uncommon.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by adventured on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:19PM (#15997346)
> people who are so poor that they don't have reliable access to banking services very often are lacking reliable access to internet connected computing devices

That's absolutely true when you get to the bottom ~3-4 billion people in the world. However it also used to be true about the ~2 billion people above them as well. Mobile banking - smart phones - have legitimately reshaped that for people in nations that have for example GDP per capita levels of around $3,000 to $8,000. It wasn't very long ago that the context for those people wasn't too dissimilar to that of what third world people are still dealing with today. Go back before ~2009 in small to mid size towns in Romania, Vietnam or Nigeria; today these people widely have access to easy, relatively secure banking via their phones. In the near future their mobile banking systems will provide easy access to something like Bitcoin as well, and obviously some of them already are.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by scythe on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:29PM (#15996603)
As society advances, the lowest rung is brought up even though corruption persists. Many years ago, it wasn't likely for people in third world countries to have access to vaccination or clothing, but today we've eliminated smallpox and nobody wears animal skins except uncontacted tribes and people who choose to. Internet connectivity is very cheap in per capita terms and cell phone towers have gone up in places like Afghanistan and Somalia.

Furthermore, the poorest people generally aren't the ones looking to evade hyperinflation, because they lack savings in the first place. Venezuela had a middle class once upon a time, though.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by root_axis on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:59PM (#15997054)
The bottom line is that blockchain token technology is not a fit for the problem of 3rd world banking and hyperinflation, it is stunningly out of touch to suggest that crpyo-tokens are having any significant impact on the ground in these places.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by scythe on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:15PM (#15997326)
You don't know anything about the bottom line. I made claims about the potential for use, not that it was actually used. You seem to be operating on the assumption that third world = mud huts and subsistence farming, which is very untrue.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by root_axis on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:56PM (#15998022)
> You don't know anything about the bottom line.

I'm unsure what you mean by this. "The bottom line" is just a manner of expression.

> I made claims about the potential for use, not that it was actually used

And I stated why I believe this to be a dubious claim; crypto-tokens are totally impractical. Your allusion to advancements in medicine and internet connectivity is a red herring argument that hand waves away the reality of using crypo-tokens in the real world.

> You seem to be operating on the assumption that third world = mud huts and subsistence farming, which is very untrue.

Wow. I illustrated concerns surrounding limited accessibility to internet in the developing world and you disingenuously twisted it into an insult to the citizens of the developing world. You don't even have to venture into a 3rd world country to see the impracticality of crypo-tokens in the real world, they're barley usable even in the developed world, and at the first sign of trouble they are useless, e.g. see how far crypo-tokens take you on the ground in Puerto Rico. Jumbling around private keys, trying to coordinate meet-ups to trade crypto for money, managing all the technical issues surrounding wallet management, insane volatility, transaction fees, the concept of confirmations, client versioning, security best practices, staying abreast of blockchain politics surrounding forks and protocol changes that impact security, price, usability... it's a quagmire of impracticality.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by dorgo on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:59PM (#16001058)
atm yes. First computers were huge, slow and impractical too.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by root_axis on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:42AM (#16007769)
> First computers were huge, slow and impractical too.

So what? Every technology starts off slow and impractical including the ones that fail.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by josu on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:00AM (#15998391)
His comment doesn't mention poor people "someone in a third-world country to keep money away from a hyperinflating currency". Not that many people living in third world countries are considered poor anymore. It is not a middle-class (European style) but they certainly are able to save some money. Banks are not interested in that low-middle-class which make up most of the population in cities like Mexico City, Sao Paolo, Kolkata or Beijing, so the only store of value they have access to are state-sponsored/controlled pension funds (which they may never get back) or real estate in areas where property rights are not that well defined. So crypto is a very real answer to these people that are connected to the internet 24/7 through their smartphones.

Your comment mostly applies to rural areas in 3rd countries.

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by aaavl2821 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:37PM (#15996387)
jewelry is a good option, as long as you can tell real jewelry from fake: valuable, somewhat liquid, holds value reasonably well, easy to hide, portable
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by adventured on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:26PM (#15997370)
You get massacred on jewelry anytime you need to actually sell it. If you paid $2,000-$3,000 for that diamond ring, you'll get $150-$200 for it from a buyer in a crunch. Jewelry being resold does anything but hold its value, it's a truly epic beating you'll take to the downside. 75-90% of the value of retail jewelry is bullshit, you're almost never paying the bulk of the retail price for the actual gold / silver / diamond, you're paying the mark-up from a store (as a validated trinket, to verify by reputation sharing that it's hopefully the real deal). Take a nice engagement ring into a pawn shop to sell it, you'll get $0.10-$0.15 on the dollar if you're lucky, and that's a good scenario where you're not under pressure to move it to an even shadier buyer.

The only way to go with the concept you're suggesting, is to buy actual gold (coins or similar). With something like gold coins, you'll still suffer a discount on a need-to-sell, but it won't be nearly so bad. Do not think under any circumstances that jewelry holds its value in a resale, it holds a small fraction of its value (unless we're talking a million dollar extraordinary specimen (equivalent to art in the jewelry world), but that's a super rare context, and you'll still sell it at a hefty discount in a crunch).

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by hanselot on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:39PM (#15996396)
This is exactly what happened in Zimbabwe.
Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by adamnemecek on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:07PM (#15996001)
“What’s the point of http when you can write a custom protocol”.

It’s not about the single solutions themselves, it’s about the ecosystem of solutions that you can integrate relatively painlessly. Same reason why standards are important.

What do you consider standard tech btw?

Re:Ten years in, nobody has come up with a use for blockchain by hanselot on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:38PM (#15996390)
It's been a while, but https://youtu.be/WnEYakUxsHU has some interesting thoughts on it. Essentially trust based companies are the logical product of blockchain, but they will require an essential shift in how we approach business.