This is kinda sorta true, but it neglects to mention that the "Southern Strategy"[1] was a real thing:
In American politics, the southern strategy was a Republican Party electoral strategy to increase political support among white voters in the South by appealing to racism against African Americans.... Republican politicians such as presidential candidate Richard Nixon and Senator Barry Goldwater developed strategies that successfully contributed to the political realignment of many white, conservative voters in the South that had traditionally supported the Democratic Party to the Republican Party.
It's hard to imagine a Klan member being a Democrat, within the past few decades.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/04/1...
I don't think all the Democratic politicians who were originally racist suddenly had a change of heart. It's my personal opinion that politicians are generally sociopaths, so it isn't a strange thing to me that most of the Democratic politicians suddenly started singing a different tune when they saw the writing on the wall.
https://www.thenation.com/article/exclusive-lee-atwaters-inf...
North Carolina's GOP was sanctioned by the Supreme Court for actively attempting to disenfranchise black people: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/07/north-c...
Then you've got this: https://twitter.com/KFILE/status/943864121497473026
People can be former racists, hell, the prior pope was in the Hitler Youth!
That said, if you want to argue Robert Byrd presence in the party, who has a 100% rating from the NAACP ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Byrd ) somehow indicates that the Democrats are institutionally racist, you are operating with some substantially motivated reasoning.
(edited because it's likely SOME Democrats are racist, but not the political party itself as an institution, unlike the GOP)
What he literally said was this:
> You start out in 1954 by saying, “Nigger, nigger, nigger.” By 1968 you can’t say “nigger”—that hurts you, backfires. So you say stuff like, uh, forced busing, states’ rights, and all that stuff, and you’re getting so abstract. Now, you’re talking about cutting taxes, and all these things you’re talking about are totally economic things and a byproduct of them is, blacks get hurt worse than whites.… “We want to cut this,” is much more abstract than even the busing thing, uh, and a hell of a lot more abstract than “Nigger, nigger.”
But think about what that is. It's a strategy for destroying racism by abstracting it into non-existence.
You have these racists who hate black people because they think they're inferior subhumans, and then a bunch of regular middle class people who don't care about race at all and just want their tax dollars to pay for their own kid's school instead of some stranger's kid, but they end up together in a majority coalition.
If you strip off the second group of people and give them what they want directly without any racial component then the first group loses all their political power. They go from 60% of people you can't ignore to 0.2% of people you can ignore.
And you can't pretend the outcome is the same either. A person can't change their skin color the same ways they can change their finances.
Do you really believe that? Not many do - most think it is a deliberately racist strategy, and most see that quote as an explanation of it.
How is it racist to remove the racist component from a policy?
It's literally the exact opposite of that. That's what optimizing to reduce the amount of racism looks like -- you find things that are partly desired and partly racist and replace them with something to achieve the desired objective without discriminating based on race.
You understand that they didn’t remove the racist component at all, right? He literally explained how to implement racist policies without making it explicit.
Like you said: replace them with something to achieve the desired objective without discriminating based on race.
But note that the desired objective is to discriminate on race, and it is only an attempt to hide the appearance.
No it isn't, that's the whole point. Most people have no real interest in discriminating based on race. They just want their tax dollars to go to their own interests instead of to somebody else. They don't care if the somebody else is black, white or polka dot. They want to pay $5000 in taxes and get back >=$5000 in government services, not pay $6000 and get back $3000.
Listen to more of the interview. It isn't that most people want to discriminate based on race and economic policies are a way to do it, it's that people want particular economic policies and direct racial discrimination was historically a way to do that. The point isn't to use economics as a proxy for race, it's to stop using race as a proxy for economics.
The two things have some similar effects, because "affects poor people" and "affects black people" are similar when poor and black correlate, but they're not actually the same and the exact difference is what makes it racism or not.
Late 60s South, the voters who used to vote for racist Democrats switched to racist Republicans even though the economic policies were complete opposites.
I think that says a lot.
Where did he literally say that? I read it as part of an argument that political racism was going to fade away as the ties between policy positions and race became more and more diffuse or abstract. Notably, the following portion was omitted from the pull quote on that The Nation page:
> But I'm saying that if it is getting that abstract, and that coded, that we are doing away with the racial problem one way or the other.
https://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-03-14/ku-klux-klan...
Sure it was a thing. The Democrats gave their base a swift kick in the teeth and the Republicans saw a bunch of easy votes. Realpolitik in action.
The whole dog whistle thing gives it away. If your base is actually full of racists then you just go out and say overtly racist things and never take it back, because your voters are racists so that gains you more votes than it costs.
It's only the marks you have to wink at and convince that you're saying something you're not. Because if you can't even say the thing out loud then you obviously can't actually do it and still get reelected.
True enough, but your point is merely a digression. Nothing you say seems to refute the argument that characterizing the modern Democratic party as the one most motivated by racial resentment is... yeah.
Come on. Republican bang the drum for the culturally scared white vote, and they've done it consistently for over half a century regardless of the fidelity with which one explains civil rights legislation.
They've changed their colors but not their tune. Historically the Republicans said that everyone should be treated equally under the law and the Democrats claimed equal treatment was bad. Today it's the same thing but they're targeting a different demographic, so they still oppose equality under the law but it's a different set of exceptions.
Democrats need black votes much more than Republicans need racist votes, because there are a lot more black people than racists in the swing states. Which means Democrats need the narrative that Republicans are all racists to stick, so they spend a lot of time telling everybody that and publicizing every little instance they can find.
The Democrats would be in serious trouble if black people started believing that entrepreneurship is the best way for their communities to get out of poverty and voting for politicians who made it easier for them to start a business.
But if entrepreneurship really is the best way for a community to get out of poverty...
> Come on. Republican bang the drum for the culturally scared white vote, and they've done it consistently for over half a century regardless of the fidelity with which one explains civil rights legislation.
Don't conflate race and culture. The difference is really important. Because the difference is that a black man willing to work two jobs to go to college so he can get a middle class paycheck and live in a middle class neighborhood with middle class schools, can actually do that. That wasn't the case a century ago. And it's important to notice that nobody of consequence is asking for that to go back to the way it was.
The problem is that Democrats are now trying to pin their mess on Republicans and pay lip service to solving it. Even when they've had a legislative majority (e.g. Obama's first term), they still don't actually fix the criminal justice system, or gang violence, or a dozen other things that are actively making life hard for poor communities.
And when they claim to have done something like the ACA, it ends up being a huge taxpayer subsidy to corporations that donate to their campaigns and an arduous bureaucracy to the people it's supposed to help.
http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/lyndon-johnson-civil-rights-racis...
Like all other politicians, I think his personal ambitions dovetailed with his ideology and the direction of his era. I think his detractors often confuse his attitudes towards class with those towards race, and his character. He grew up brutally poor and struggled in his professional class closely with issues of class, especially given his position as the ‘dumb’ southerner in Kennedy’s pedigreed cabinet. He was a voracious advocate of the poor Mexican children he taught, pushed them to succeed relentlessly, and tutored the school janitor in English for free because he was convinced his inability to speak English was hindering him. I think his entire career often struggled with issues of class and inequality, and his personal instinct to the lesser was typically compassionate and generous. He was known to have a temper and a flare for knowing how to touch people’s insecurities and nerves, and also for his ability to find and build emotional coherence in those positions he found politically advantageous. He also loved jokes, and didn’t care much about who they were at the expense of.
But ultimately he could have found a more natural path to power in racial demagoguery that was so rampant in the south, and the political cohesion behind the southern democrats at that time gave him a natural base of power to launch a presidential bid. But he chose the more arduous work of breaking down the south’s racial hierarchy at great cost to his professional relationships.
I think Caro said it best, that power ultimately doesn’t corrupt, but rather reveal someone’s true nature - and LBJ used his shot at power to write compassion and mercy into the federal statutes. He fought ferociously to give the civil rights and voting acts real power, and handed minorities the greatest legislative weapon they had since Thaddeus Russell outlawed slavery.
That is an oversimplification.
What happened is that overtly racist policies fell out of favor. People talk about structural racism today, but nobody can say with a straight face that it's the same now as it was in the days of Jim Crow laws.
By the 1960s the Democrats saw the writing on the wall. The political winds were changing and they adjusted their sail. But supporting Jim Crow had been how Democrats got elected in the south. By voting with the Republicans to pass the Civil Rights Act, they alienated all the old racists who voted for them specifically to prevent that from happening.
The south was ready to skin them and eat them at that point. The Republicans weren't too stupid to realize that. All they had to do to take the south was to show up and be Not The Democrats.
Some racists (e.g. Strom Thurmond) switched parties, but in general the Republicans were never as racist as the Democrats historically were. They didn't have to be. Popular support for racism has been on the decline for more than a hundred years, and the remaining racists no longer trusted the Dems so the Republicans never had to give them anything or even really promise to give them anything to get their votes.
It's not so much that the Republicans flipped as that the racists lost and that redrew the electoral map.