This is, of course, largely how firms trading with their own money work, but not historically how VC firms operate.
I also don't see how that's enough money to tip the scale.
For reference, we started offering the 401k before our A round. At that point, we had raised $2M and were still under $1M ARR run rate. Based in the Bay Area.
I don’t get the narrative that startups pay very little or don’t offer any benefits. We pay competitive comp and offer good benefits to get great people. We’re an enterprise SaaS company, so maybe pre-revenue or consumer or hit-based companies are different. But even our first employee was well compensated. Though at that point, my cofounder and I were paying ourselves well below market and were living off savings.
We're entirely bootstrapped, but we provide a recurring service and it's taken me 2 years to hire our first employee. I don't think most companies can wait 2 years after launching to hire an employee (We couldn't even.. I had to bring in short-term help on numerous occasions).
We went just over two years in our venture-backed company before hiring anyone. Built the business to nearly $200k ARR. Everyone we told was amazed. But if 2 people can’t operate a business with only $200k top line, you don’t need a complex financial model to know that your economics aren’t where they need to be.
So, yes, you need to have revenues and cash before you can hire and pay salaries. 401k is only a little further out than that.
I was curious what this could mean in reality so I did some back of the envelope math. (As a disclaimer - I have no inside knowledge of the performance of YC's portfolio, so all this math could be wrong.) YC Summer '17 had 294 founders at 124 startups. Let's say there is an Airbnb ($30 billion to common at liquidity) and three smaller but still substantial exits ($1 billion, $500 million and $250 million respectively, same terms). The rest of the class is a wash after expenses and fees which leaves $31,750,000,000 to split up. On a side note, every time I do this math I'm reminded how the ten figure exits really carry the rest of the valley along for the ride; whether there is one in your class or not is a roll of the dice.
YC keeps 4% for themselves (out of which they generally fund expenses and management fees) and puts 3% (with no carry) into the common class pool, divided equally by startup (not founder, to avoid perverse incentives around cramming). In other words, the YC Summer '17 class collectively owns 3% of every member company. After ten years the 3% has been diluted down by follow on rounds to 1.5%. At liquidity, the fund returns 1.5% of $31.175 billion: $467,625,000. Divided among 294 founders equally (which it wouldn't be, as mentioned above - but for easy math) that's about $1.5 million per founder.
If you miss the class with an Airbnb, Uber, or Snapchat and end up with (merely) a few traditional unicorns, the returns decline 90% to a couple hundred thousand dollars per founder, a.k.a. not that exciting financially. So it seems like a gamble.
Still, I like the spirit of the whole idea. As a lifelong entrepreneur who hasn't quite pulled the trigger on applying to YC this might push me over the edge. It would definitely feel like being part of a grander experiment of some kind.