Re:The ABC conjecture has still not been proved
by qmalzp on Thursday December 21, 2017 @11:14AM
(#15979927)
Probably because at the end of the day, he doesn't want to fight some legal battle, he wants to do mathematics.
Re:The ABC conjecture has still not been proved
by hyperpape on Thursday December 21, 2017 @11:54AM
(#15980452)
In addition (not a lawyer here, but I believe this is well established territory), defamation is difficult to prove, and suing someone over an article almost always carries some negative press, regardless of the merits.
Re:The ABC conjecture has still not been proved
by WhitneyLand on Thursday December 21, 2017 @11:51PM
(#15985352)
That’s the point, I mentioned the difficulty in fact. But he chose to step across that bridge and then abandon it. What else can we conclude other than, heat of the moment emotional decision, or that the merits were, if morally strong enough, not legally strong enough?
There was never any apology or retraction seeming to remove settlement an a possible result.
I have no reason to doubt the claims against the article, at first glance there are a significant number of credible sources supporting the idea the article was flawed, yet the claims were ineffective legally.
Of course it’s not easy or cheap to pursue a case of defamation, however, I think it money was the issue he could have rallied some public support. If I were asked, it’s certainly an issue I would do the due diligence on and contribute something to if it made sense.
edit: btw why is no one making a movie about this? There are so many fascinating aspects, the grand challenge, the controversy, the mathematician who declined a million dollar prize. I’d love to do even a documentary on it, or watch one if it’s been done.