Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ...
by mikeash on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:14PM
(#15976118)
How likely are delays in other parts of the project? There are plenty of things that could be delayed and would physically prevent train service from running on the line. Is it really such a massive risk to to say that safety equipment must be installed before operations begin, even if the train could potentially make the run without it?
I don't know about that "quite safe" thing. I looked up the stats in another comment in this tree and they look pretty bad for trains.
Also, define "ready". Is it ready when it's running, but is only 75% likely to actually stop a train if needed because of various bugs? (Note well: I do not know what PTC's bug track record is. I just know that such systems often have bugs that take a while to work out.)
In the real world, projects that wait for everything to be ready before they ship at all are often very late.
On the other hand, you don't ship something without basic safety features. So it all depends on whether you view PTC as a basic safety feature. (After the crash, it's easy to say "obviously it is", but I'm not sure that it's fair to use hindsight that way. PTC was supposed to be a small increment of safety to an already quite safe mode of transportation.)