News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by bogomipz on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:10PM (#15975781)
>"Railroads are under government orders to install positive train control by the end of 2018 after the industry lobbied Congress to extend earlier deadlines, citing complexity and cost"

Amtrak receives well over a billion dollars a year in subsidies from the US Federal government[1], they should not be allowed to use cost as an excuse for not modernizing safety.

Also I think if you sight safety as being too complex then maybe you have no business operating a monopoly passenger rail service. Lawmakers are just as much to blame for this tragedy as the incompetence and disregard at Amtrak.

[1] https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/2013/44782

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by tjohns on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:39PM (#15975945)
My understanding is that many modern Amtrak locomotives are equipped with PTC. Either way, the problem was that the track was not yet equipped with the necessary transmitters to communicate with the train (and isn't yet mandated to, since the railroad industry keeps lobbying to move the implementation date forward).

In Amtrak's defense, my understanding is that this track was actually owned by WSDOT / Sound Transit. And the mainline track (privately) owned by Union Pacific / BNSF isn't any better. Amtrak owns very little track of it's own on the west coast.

The failure to deploy PTC is a systemic issue with the entire railroad industry.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by AstralStorm on Thursday December 21, 2017 @07:54AM (#15978417)
In Poland we still have the relatively medieval central radio and lights or semaphore system, tiered with rules to override it via radio plus really dumb automated braking system with train central detector, also enforcing speed limits in more advanced versions.

Plain old local moving block systems are widespread but US does not mandate them. These are all mandatory (esp. the wired one where light or semaphore control is tied to NTC and/or PTC) And the system is really dumb and electrical, not electronic. It is considered one of Automatic Train Protection systems. (The Polish short is SHP, translated as Automated Train Braking. The other system is Radio-Stop, a dumb radio alert system of local range triggered mostly manually forcing braking of all cabs in range.)

Similar slightly more modern systems are still used throughout Europe. The fact they are dumb (train is only slightly smarter) makes them cheap to deploy. They are mostly supervised or not automated other than the moving block light signal. (Which is often local and can be overridden at low speed only after radio confirmation.)

SHP is placed before speed limits and stations to alert the conductor. And if you pass the second one while the first is not cleared it means the train is runway and automated breaking is applied. The "logic" is in the train.

Compared to this Amtrak style PTC needs a big central computer system and control lines plus a train with an impressive array of sensors with remote data. Similar to ERTMS class 3.

US used to have legacy inductive systems in place, but for dumb cost saving reasons the companies were allowed to nor install them anymore.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by justicezyx on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:24PM (#15976167)
Classic "obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility"...

My problem, not my problem, his problem, not his problem... What a stupid situation...

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:36PM (#15976466)
Amtrak doesn’t really make a profit on its own. Anyone who has ever travelled portland to Seattle knows how slow it can be as freight gets priority.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by dawnerd on Thursday December 21, 2017 @12:04AM (#15976581)
Pretty much true for the entire coast - not to mention outright expensive. I looked at a ticket from Portland to la and it was more than a flight and they’d probably stick me on a bus in Bakersfield.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by bogomipz on Thursday December 21, 2017 @12:56PM (#15981081)
Then it should be broken up and managed differently. The idea that a company with a sanctioned monopoly who receives over a billion dollars a year in subsidies loses money is absurd.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by seanmcdirmid on Thursday December 21, 2017 @05:04PM (#15983255)
You are basically demanding that the service should not exist. No one will compete for these routes, very few train systems in the world are profitable in themselves (even JR would lose money if it wasn’t for train station real estate).
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by bogomipz on Thursday December 21, 2017 @07:57PM (#15984396)
No I am not "basically demanding" that the service should not exist. There is no reason why smaller regional companies couldn't exist and be profitable, offer better service and provide a compelling alternative to buses.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday December 21, 2017 @12:09AM (#15976602)
It's worse when Amtrack does have priority and their habitually late trains block other trains that could be using the track.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by AdamJacobMuller on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:48PM (#15976000)
Amtrak owns very little track of it's own, period.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by astronautjones on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:59PM (#15976328)
What could go wrong?
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by gt_ on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:56PM (#15976031)
What I understand, which has at least been consistent with my experience riding many routes in most regions of the country, is that Amtrak is hindered by having to yield to freight, which takes priority in the US.

It's very rare to take Amtrak and not spend what can often be many consecutive hours waiting at a junction for a freight train to pass. Of course freight and passenger trains travel at very different speeds so the problem has no solution that even billions of dollars can solve, and it's only compounded by the vast distances of single-lane track in the US, which serve the purposes of freight needs just fine.

The difference in operation and overhead requirements for each use cannot be overstated. Besides a few routes in the Northeast and the Socal coastline, traveling by Amtrack is a novelty or a mistake. Competing with airlines on any route is far from realistic. I used to take this train between Portland and Seattle before it was beat by a <$20 twice-a-day bus program with good marketing and free wi-fi, relegating the train to being only a bit more comfortable and about $60 more expensive (and now more scary). I've been on >10 hour Amtrak rides which had no more than 2 people per car! When you run a route once every few days, you can't just shift people around like the airlines do. Without the subsidies, Amtrak simply doesn't exist.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by ikawe on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:41PM (#15976239)
> It's very rare to take Amtrak and not spend what can often be many consecutive hours waiting at a junction for a freight train to pass.

Its true that Amtrak often has to yield to freight on a lot of rail, but saying its “rare” to ride without being stuck for “hours” seems a gross exaggeration, or at least starkly different from my own rides. (Up and down west coast, northeast corridor, a couple times across the middle - highly recommended if you have a few days to spare).

Usually it’s 5 minutes of waiting, and for me I don’t recall ever more than 20.

Riding across the entire country (Oakland -> Philadelphia) I probably accrued 30 minutes of waiting.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by gt_ on Thursday December 21, 2017 @02:04PM (#15981772)
I could have pressed on it more, but I think the Southern California coastline and the frequented routes in the Northeast are the only exception here.

It sounds like your trip across country was quite lucky. I've never done trips quite as long as coast-to-coast but I've taken some odd routes. I love the train for writing, so I do it a few times a year.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:39PM (#15976477)
I have never been on the train between portland and Seattle without yielding for at least an hour.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by vvanders on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:44PM (#15976259)
I think that varies on a rail-by-rail basis. I was chatting on 2 meters the other day with someone who does transport with BNSF on the route this train runs and in that case at least freight yields to passenger trains.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by mulmen on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:34PM (#15975918)
Agreed on all points. In this case is there a (e:) more competent passenger carrier that could step in to replace Amtrak? My understanding of the subsidies is that there would be no passenger service without it. Is it feasible to have competitive rail service in the US, does anyone do it?
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by niftich on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:20PM (#15976146)
Amtrak actually makes a profit [1][2] on both Acela and the slower services in the Northeast Corridor, but not anywhere else.

If we suppose that a privatized passenger carrier would want to make a profit, shedding long-distance trains would be wise, but several Amtrak directors have been against doing so time and time again.

[1] http://reasonrail.blogspot.com/2012/12/amtrak-routes-by-2012... [2] http://www.riarp.org/blog/2014/11/25/september-amtrak-report

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by rayiner on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:19PM (#15976142)
If a private carrier were allowed to take over the northeast regional segment and abandon everything else, it might be feasible. Amtrak runs a profit on this segment, but only because Congress foots the capital expenditures. But maybe a private entity could harness cost efficiencies to make it.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by hnpobdo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:48PM (#15975996)
Except this accident happened on tracks amtrak doesn’t own - and on the tracks amtrak owns the system is already in place.
Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by bogomipz on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:17PM (#15976131)
Except the lobbying effort to delay the roll out of PTC was done by the Association of American Railroads[1], of which Amtrak is a full member with much influence.[2]

The buck always stops somewhere else.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/dea...

[2] https://www.aar.org/Pages/AARMembers.aspx

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by saalweachter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:04PM (#15976343)
If Amtrak has in fact implemented PTC on all of the tracks they control, I would blame the freight railroads who are the other 20 full members of the AAR.

If Amtrak is also stalling on implementing PTC on their own tracks, yeah, I'd stop the buck at them.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by bogomipz on Thursday December 21, 2017 @12:08PM (#15980602)
>"If Amtrak has in fact implemented PTC on all of the tracks they control, I would blame the freight railroads who are the other 20 full members of the AAR."

This is exactly the logic everyone has been using to absolve themselves from any blame. 'Yes it was our train and our customers but it wasn't our track.'

If Amtrak is doesn't want to take any responsibility for peoples lives when they offer service on tracks they don't "control" then they should restrict their routes to tracks they do control. People who purchase fares on Amtrak should have a reasonable expectation that the carrier uses routes that meet modern safety standards.

Re:Amtrak derailment: safety gear was not active after rush ... by heisenbit on Thursday December 21, 2017 @07:10AM (#15978241)
The deadlines were extended for short term financial considerations. The law makers responsible for it should be named. Unlike the executive branch messing up in Flint and killing people the legislative branch can only be made accountable by the people.