News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Irony punctuation by jrockway on Thursday August 12, 2010 @02:07AM (#1597363)
Sarcasm is most interesting when you don't "wink, change the tone of your voice or just start grinning". Good sarcasm is detectable as such even without any change in inflection, which is why there is no need to mark it in writing.

I also disagree that smileys are widely used to mark sarcasm; they mark any sort of situation where you might smile. Most of the time, this is just some sort of happy statement, like "now go get some sleep ;)" when someone emails you at 3 in the morning.

Re:Irony punctuation by nandemo on Thursday August 12, 2010 @06:42AM (#1597738)
Sarcasm is most interesting when you don't "wink, change the tone of your voice or just start grinning".

Whoa there, jrockway. Soon you'll be proposing sitcoms without laugh tracks.

Re:Irony punctuation by ugh on Thursday August 12, 2010 @02:22AM (#1597392)
I’m not sure you are disagreeing with me. ‘Good’ (using scare quotes here because I think the fake kind is also a valuable tool) sarcasm is fucking hard to pull off! That’s why you hardly ever see it. That’s why writers didn’t need a typographic sign.

And sure, the winking smiley is also used for other things but do you really want to claim that it’s not widely used for marking irony? If it were easier to search for ‘;-)’ I would probably be able to quote a few dozen examples here on HN alone in no time.

Re:Irony punctuation by jrockway on Thursday August 12, 2010 @02:32AM (#1597410)
I would probably be able to quote a few dozen examples here on HN alone in no time.

Maybe those people are just using it wrong ;)

Re:Irony punctuation by ugh on Thursday August 12, 2010 @03:04AM (#1597456)
See, here’s how I would parse that: Clearly, there is no way marking sarcasm with a winking smiley could be considered ‘using it wrong’ because there isn’t anything like rules for emoticon usage (and if there were that would be stupid), hence I’m tacitly agreeing with your comment.

Amazing ;-)