Re:Bitcoin Is a Terrible Currency, and Not for the Reason Yo...
by nine_k on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:12PM
(#15973870)
Agreed! Tulips are an imperfect analogy. The only analogous part is the rally, which is not due to the intrinsic value of the item (gold is ornamental, a paper can pay coupons or dividends, etc), but due to the bandwagon effect.
Tulips come from seeds and are ornamental, once they are dead they can no longer be traded for value. There is no limit to the world-wide supply of tulips, and there is no such thing as distributed international observation and participation in tulips.
To further my antagonist response, the Smithsonian Mag recently did a report explaining that Tulip Mania was also not really a Tulip Mania and that reports were highly exaggerated; an author of a recent book on that time claims that there really is no lesson to learn from Tulip Mania, as tempting as the comparison may be.
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/there-never-was-real-...