News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:57AM (#15971307)
> the devil is in the details, and the FCC seems to have the power to write those details

The bill explicitly prohibits the FCC from writing rules fleshing out the details, and restricts the FCC to adjudicating specific cases (such adjudications are subject individually to review by the courts, so inasmuch as someone is empowered to define general standards, it's the course through case law, not the FCC, whose adjudications do not create binding precedent.)

The FCC is that of essentially a trial court, not a rulemakers, under this bill.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by ensignavenger on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:47PM (#15971895)
The bill only explicitly forbids them from expanding the obligations. It does specify that the FCC has authority to adjudicate complaints. I don't know if that prevents them from publishing guidelines ahead of time, or if that will evolve from adjudication. And, as you point out, the courts will ultimately have oversight over the adjudication- so I suppose in the end, the Supreme Court may end up writing the rules... Of course, this is an early proposal, maybe the final bill will provide the FCC/courts with more guidance.

Why don't we provide feedback to our representatives and work with them on how the Bill can be improved by providing more guidance on rules and penalties?

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:17PM (#15972790)
> The bill only explicitly forbids them from expanding the obligations

Any rule which restricted anything not restricted by the bare law would expand obligations, and is thereby prohibited.