News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by def_true_false on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:50AM (#15970555)
> doesn't have a shady track record

Care to expand on that?

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by munchbunny on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:02PM (#15972646)
A couple years ago, on top of their acceptable ads program that was more or less pay-to-bypass, Eeyo announced that it was going to start an ad exchange to let people buy placements on spots that ABP blocked.

In effect ABP was forcing itself in as a middle man and taking a fee from both the site owner and the advertiser. As an example, if I, your local newspaper, sell a placement to your local car dealership, ABP comes in and says "people won't see the car ads, but if you split the revenue you were going to get with me, I'll sell those placements to someone else for you." So let's say 10% of my visitors use ABP. I can now either lose it or get back some smaller percentage of it by paying ABP.

That's one DDoS short of a digital protection racket.

In addition, when Eeyo made that announcement, they also announced that they were working with AppNexus and Google on the new exchange, which just wasn't true. Though I believe Google does pay to get some ads into the acceptable ads program.

If you're going to be in the business of blocking ads, stay out of the business of selling ads.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by mindslight on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:26PM (#15972853)
> That's one DDoS short of a digital protection racket.

Your specific condemnation rests on this tired narrative that "ad spots" are something belonging to the site owner. In the reality of the web, it's all the user's display area - the user agent decides what and how to render.

The real critique is that the software is working against the user's interest for its own gain. This is par for the course of proprietary software, but generally seen as unsustainable poor taste in the Free world. Fortunately, having achieved the activation energy of installing extensions for one's self, switching is not hard.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by munchbunny on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:00PM (#15973201)
> In the reality of the web

I'm willing to concede that I assume a specific view of the nature of ad spots, but you're going to have to reeeeeeaaaaally stretch your argument to claim that this is the reality of the web. For the vast majority of people the browser is the renderer that happens to be customizable, not the arbiter of what is rendered, regardless of the browser's capability to decide.

Regardless, you don't have to accept the online advertising business model, even at a moral level, to acknowledge the shadiness of the other aspects of the practice that I pointed out.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by Macha on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:56AM (#15970618)
The eventual setup of their acceptable ads policy ended up being seen as pay-to-whitelist by users and advertisers.

It felt that way to advertisers especially when the fee was 30% of ad revenue rather than say, a processing fee for time spent verifying it met the criteria. A lot of them were more ok to ignore ad blocking before they were held to ransom.

Users were unhappy at an adblocker's default config allowing ads.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by def_true_false on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:48AM (#15971201)
I can see why people would be upset, but it doesn't seem especially shady to me - they were upfront about what they are doing and why. I do remember that multiple forks appeared immediately, but I don't see how trusting someone else in addition to the ABP developers is an improvement... until UBO there was nothing to switch to, and UBO had other advantages.
Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by epicide on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:58PM (#15973172)
So as long as I tell you I'm screwing you over, it's okay?
Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by DarronWyke on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:55AM (#15971280)
And it can be turned off. It's not a big deal at all. People are making mountains out of molehills.
Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by Fnoord on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:59AM (#15971319)
Ah, so opt-out is suddenly totally OK.

A feature being able to be turned off is a plus, but default features not in the interest of the user are a minus. Especially not when users don't have an easy way to opt-out.

If users reasonably want to only opt-in such a feature, you as developer should implement it as such.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by UncleEntity on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:41PM (#15971828)
> Especially not when users don't have an easy way to opt-out.

When I first heard about it took me like 35 seconds to opt-out -- open options and unclick the little clicky box, easy peasy.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by Fnoord on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:57PM (#15971996)
Good for you. If I need to be happy every time I opt-out "when I hear about it" which is often "when I already used the software" and get USDs for every hour I didn't opt-out even though I'd have loved to opt-out right away, then I'd be one hell of a happy Richie Rich.

Having to go through settings in software when you install it, to get the software to work the way the average user wants it to, is annoying. An example could be removing a bitcoin miner from the software, or disabling ads in uTorrent, or disabling telemetry in Windows 10. Firefox as well, but at least they tell you about it right away, and they started doing it later. Not good, but less bad.

Why do software developers get away treating their customers like stupid sheep either wasting their time or getting their data? Ah well, at least in Europe we're getting GDPR.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by UncleEntity on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:21PM (#15972819)
> Good for you. If I need to be happy every time I opt-out "when I hear about it" which is often "when I already used the software" and get USDs for every hour I didn't opt-out even though I'd have loved to opt-out right away, then I'd be one hell of a happy Richie Rich.

It's not like they owe me anything, I downloaded their software for free and use it for free with absolutely no expectation other than "I'll use it as long as it works for me."

If it gets annoying I'll replace it with something that isn't just in this particular case it was a lot easier to click a box than search out a new adblocker.

> Why do software developers get away treating their customers like stupid sheep either wasting their time or getting their data?

Because they want to use Windows 10 or uTorrent or something with a bitcoin miner instead of searching out alternatives. Personally, other than ABP, I can think of no other cases of this happening on my stock (other than the chrome repo) Fedora box.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by Fnoord on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:05PM (#15973249)
I know its strange in 2017 and for youngsters in general (and that's NOFI; its a general observation and zeitgeist; I don't know your age nor am I interested in such) but it is important to note that "for free" doesn't equal "go use my PII for profit" or "go help others receive my PII" or "I will allow you to use my computer as part of your cloud without my consent".

Glad we're getting GDPR in EU. I hope other countries like USA will follow suit. US citizens deserve such protection just as much as EU citizens. Not to mention the rest of the world. We'll have to see how it works out in practice though.

As for the owing and such regarding FOSS, that's related to warranty and such. That doesn't mean its cool to deliver the software crippled. Especially not without mentioning it is crippled beforehand. We got a word for that in the physical world: dishonesty.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by UncleEntity on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:45PM (#15974126)
> I know its strange in 2017 and for youngsters in general (and that's NOFI; its a general observation and zeitgeist; I don't know your age nor am I interested in such) but it is important to note that "for free" doesn't equal "go use my PII for profit" or "go help others receive my PII" or "I will allow you to use my computer as part of your cloud without my consent".

Which is why you should use some due diligence before (and after) choosing which products you use. It's not like anyone's forcing you to sell your soul so you can find out your best friend's dog Fluffy just went to the groomers and here's the pictures.

I see this like those people who go and buy a house next to an airport then go crazy complaining to the city about airplane noise, they benefit from cheaper prices (because most people don't actually want to live next to an airport) but then feel entitled enough to feel everyone else should bend over backwards for their personal preferences.

> Glad we're getting GDPR in EU...We'll have to see how it works out in practice though.

Produce a digital wasteland IMHO...like the tariff wars that (partly) led up to the Great Depression.

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by Fnoord on Thursday December 21, 2017 @06:00AM (#15977888)
Lets draw an analogy with the physical world to see how it works there (often terrible, cringe worthy analogies, I admit!). If I buy a product, I should have to read the manual, sure. Afterwards, before using it. If some tool has a dangerous side effect or important feature I should take into account the salesman would have to tell me about it. Beforehand. If I buy a CD, but I can only play it on computers and not on discman or CD player, it has to be advertised as such. Well, at least it was that way in the 90s in my jurisdiction.

In the previous century I did not expect any tool to send back data about usage (including my private data). Back then it was called phoning home [1]. It was very much frowned upon. Although, as the internet took off, it started to become more rampant as a way to verify software. For example, I remember a personal firewall trying to phone home to verify it was licensed which you could block with... itself. Later they fixed that, but you could just use a hex editor to fix that.

Nowadays we've migrated from pay to use model (proprietary software) to service for your privacy model (SaaS). We get disillusioned that things are free when in reality they're not. In the physical world, but more so in the digital world. We don't know how we are paying, and that's a problem. [2]

> I see this like those people who go and buy a house next to an airport then go crazy complaining to the city about airplane noise, they benefit from cheaper prices (because most people don't actually want to live next to an airport) but then feel entitled enough to feel everyone else should bend over backwards for their personal preferences.

No, those people knew beforehand what they were buying. We don't, else we'd change those settings right away. Claiming that people consent to their privacy being discarded is dishonest. They don't fully understand the effect of their actions. The developers do know, but they don't care, maybe cause they're aspies who can keep distance from that --I'm not sure.

As for people who live near an airport, I happen to know a tad bit more about that with regards to the airport near Amsterdam (I live near Amsterdam). It all depends on the flight routes (the lanes for landing and take off). For example, I don't hear any airplanes except in the summer because then that specific route is used more. Not every 15 minutes though like my aunt who lives a few km from one lane in the Green Heart on a boat with a beautiful land. With, during the summer (winter etc less), planes going over. Low. Every. 15. Minutes. It would drive me nuts.

> Produce a digital wasteland IMHO...like the tariff wars that (partly) led up to the Great Depression.

How so? Look back at what I wrote here [2]. Don't you think the GDPR will make it very transparent to users because they have to give their consent?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoning_home

[2] See other [2]

Re:Taking a break from Adblock Plus development by hutzlibu on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @06:08PM (#15974723)
"Why do software developers get away treating their customers like stupid sheep"

Not only the software developers and to why? Well because it works, because most act like sheep.

I wonder how much of that comes from having been dominated for century's by a religion who literally told (and tell) all the people that they are sheep, needings them as shepherds ...