You've missed my point. There are some ways an ISP can go faster that are not neutral AND not malicious/extortive. If google puts a GGC on your ISPs network, youtube now has an advantage over hulu. There is no equivalent internal-deployment that can give a truly neutral increase in capacity.
To conflate this with active degradation (throttling or blocking) means that you would have an ISP be unable to host any service until they can guarantee _all services_ equivalent access (presumably at the ISPs expense otherwise they would price out everyone but the big players).
Before you immediately chose "neutral hosting" realize that it is untenable for every random small website to be able to legally demand any ISPs host their services for free in order to guarantee a level playing field with Google and Netflix. The only tenable solution is to make it illegal to collocate services which will be a far worse hit to the experience you have on the web than any throttling or blocking has ever been.
This is not as simple as you would like it to be.
> If ISPs can go faster, and they choose not to unless you pay more, that is a form of degradation
This is assuming intent and over-simplifying. Is a small regional ISP without the capital or credit necessary to expand now anti-NN by default? Are they extorting their customers by default? Not all ISPs are Comcast and Verizon. If you cannot escape your circumstance and see the bigger picture of how and what the internet is and who "ISPs" are then you are just being selfish.
We need laws or regulations to address the fact that ISPs are actually forcing content providers to deploy in-network CDN nodes with the ISPs through extortive refusal to upgrade the links between the residential ISPs and the ISPs serving Netflix et al. Some deployment of local CDN nodes makes sense on its own and benefits both parties, but it's not like video streaming is actually latency-sensitive or anything.
If Netflix did not have PNIs to Comcast, Comcast internet would have been unusable for everyone.
[Edit: Post more downvotes]
Guess what happens to the Netflix traffic when the best route to Netflix is over Comcast transit?
Only under the assumption that Comcast makes no attempt to do their job properly and uphold their contractual obligations by implementing reasonable QoS measures and upgrading their capacity. You can't point to Comcast's extortionist refusal to upgrade their links to the outside world and say that it's Netflix's fault; that was just their abusive tactic to force Netflix to deal with Comcast directly on Comcast's terms. Verizon did the same thing.
Fuck you. You aren't even trying to have a reasonable conversation, are you?
You're welcome to attempt to argue that there's an unavoidable equivalence between QoS as everybody defines it and the other concept you're trying to equate it to, but you have to actually make that argument, not just declare the definition of QoS to have changed because you don't like what it means. QoS still stands for Quality of Service.
> But hey, yes, NN is telling me I should at best use RED to do QoS as everything else requires lookng at protocol and destination
You can use CoDel without violating any principles of net neutrality. You can even use FQ-CoDel without violating the principles of net neutrality, because it only looks at port numbers to determine which packets are related to each other; each port is subjected to the same set of rules and no port is preferred over another. Net neutrality doesn't require you to ignore the past 20+ years of research into QoS.
It may help your political cause to regard QoS as being strictly a zero-sum game, but that doesn't make it true.
> There's not a single network that can provide this kind of capacity even at 10Mbit/sec, not to mention at 50Mbit/sec or 150Mbit/sec or Gigabit/sec.
> The only way to deal with this is PNIs between those that originate massive amounts of traffic and the networks that consume massive amounts of traffic.
The technical requirements of having large, reasonably direct links between big producers and big consumers does not say anything about whether Netflix has to negotiate with Comcast and Verizon directly, or whether they can outsource those concerns to Level 3. That's purely in the domain of business shenanigans.
QoS being a quantity of service is a very well known term, pioneered and popularized by Dave Rand/Avi Freedman to describe that QOS establishes which packets are to be dropped on the floor first. QOS might work OK on networks with microspikes but it completely breaks on networks that are > 20% oversubscribed.
If I were made to pick between positions of Dave Rand and Avi Freedman and positions of all people supporting Net Neutrality, I would go with the first two as those people actually built networks.
> Net neutrality doesn't require you to ignore the past 20+ years of research into QoS.
This only works within a single AS. It has been demonstrated when a pair of crazy dudes built a Sprintlink on a top of ANS without ANS' knowledge.
> The technical requirements of having large, reasonably direct links between big producers and big consumers does not say anything about whether Netflix has to negotiate with Comcast and Verizon directly, or whether they can outsource those concerns to Level 3. That's purely in the domain of business shenanigans.
It does. Without that you end up with Enron.
So you're still trying to re-define the literal text of what the "QoS" initialism expands to, and now you're also trying to narrow the scope of QoS as defined by everybody else.
There's more to QoS than just deciding which packet to drop. You also have to decide when to drop a packet. This second aspect is what makes QoS not a zero-sum game when faced with real-world traffic.
> QOS might work OK on networks with microspikes but it completely breaks on networks that are > 20% oversubscribed.
What exactly do you mean by "microspikes"?
20% oversubscription is laughably small compared to the disparity between my 1GbE LAN and my 50Mbps WAN connection. QoS makes a world of difference for the users on my LAN. Oversubscription just means you'll actually get the opportunity to notice the difference between having QoS and having a dumb FIFO. Nobody's actually asking for a circuit-switched Internet, or anything that would require a circuit-switched Internet.
You have 1Mbit/sec worth of traffic and the max connection speed is 10Mbit/sec. Packet loss is at 0% and latency is speed of light + speed of forwarding.
Do you need QoS in this case?
It doesn't have to be "actively" slowing down traffic to be degraded. If ISPs can go faster, and they choose not to unless you pay more, that is a form of degradation. One of many forms the degradation could come in is ISPs failing to build out faster networks until people are paying higher prices. Service can be allowed to degrade over time by simply not doing anything unless you pay more money.