News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by gravy on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:50AM (#15969427)
How is this different from me paying for more for faster internet?
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:07AM (#15969556)
Because the last mile is (sometimes) truly bandwidth limited. But the trunk lines aren't. Now they just get to extort money from us or artificially throttle us. Worse, they'll likely (as they have everywhere else) extort money for websites they have no connection to (like Facebook or Twitter) just because they can. Like an entrepreneurial thug standing outside a club and extracting an extra fee to let folks in. Or paying protection money to the mob. Like that.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by gravy on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:40PM (#15974084)
It was a question of genuine curiosity. Thanks. How do the regulations or whatever it is that was repealed stop them from doing so?

I actually have no idea what was repealed.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by notyourday on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:26AM (#15969723)
Exactly opposite. Last line is not bandwidth limited - FTTH exists. FIOS and even comcast do that.

100 people at 1Gbit/sec to the edge are 100Gbit/sec in the core to content providers.

[Edit: Downvoting 2+2 being 4 is stupid]

1 Gbit/sec is easily deliverable at the edge, even if it costs 5 thousand dollars to get it connected. 1 Gbit/sec of non-oversubscribed IP transit is at least $500/mo. A building with 100 apartments would require $50,000 a month in IP transit costs. This does not include costs of the long distance fiber, locations for PNI and gear that can do 48x 100Gbit/sec ports. So your Interwebz is going to cost you either > $600 a month or you get congestion and that congestion would be coming from the core, not from the edge

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:58AM (#15970643)
Sure the last mile is arguable - not for me, as I live in the country and DSL is what I get. But we could invest and do better there too.

Still its nothing compared to the extortion racket, holding websites hostage .

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by wtallis on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:33AM (#15970391)
You're replying to a comment about the current state of existing infrastructure by talking about the theoretical possibility of new infrastructure that could be deployed with today's technology, but largely isn't being deployed.
Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by notyourday on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:37AM (#15970429)
That's something that you should bring up with your local government. It is your local government that is blocking roll outs of FTTH.

Even at 10Mbit/sec congestion will be at the core. Comcast currently claims to have 22.3 million internet customers. At 10 Mbit/sec it means 223.3 MILLION megabit per second that needed to be handed off to transit. It is not possible.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by wtallis on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:00AM (#15970662)
> That's something that you should bring up with your local government. It is your local government that is blocking roll outs of FTTH.

That's definitely not true in my specific case, and probably isn't true all that often in the general case. Deploying FTTH to existing paying customers who already have halfway decent infrastructure doesn't have a very compelling short-term return on investment even when the local government is doing everything they can to encourage it.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by notyourday on Thursday December 21, 2017 @10:58AM (#15979693)
They are blocking competitors from installing fiber via franchise agreements or requirement that entire municipality is wired.

By doing that your municipality is preventing price competition on the physical last mile which means that Comcast has no need to upgrade service.

Re:GOP net neutrality bill would allow paid fast lanes and p... by snarfy on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:54AM (#15969996)
It hurts entrepreneurs a lot more than the end user. With tiered internet comes tiered pricing and tiered access. 'Basic' internet will get you google.com, facebook, etc. If you get the 'sports' package then you get espn.com. If you get the 'DIY' package you get some howto sites, craftsy, maybe thingiverse.

But what if you come up with a brand new DIY site that you wish to host ads, have logins and accounts with monthly fees, etc. How will anybody ever see your site with tiered internet? Your new site is not be in any of the predetermined packages. You would have to go to the ISP and beg/pay them to get your site added to the 'DIY' package just to even get any traffic at all, let alone users. It totally destroys innovation and tilts the playing field towards the existing incumbents.