News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by mulletbum on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:46AM (#15969391)
Can anyone say what they will do during the first real launch? Where would they be trying to go to? How does a test like that work? I love space, I just have no idea how they actually would do a test of that magnitude.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by mabbo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:49AM (#15969411)
They're going to launch Elon Musk's Telsa Roadster into orbit of the sun, possibly to Mars orbit.

I'm not even joking. That's the goal.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by lscharen on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:56AM (#15969467)
I often think of this kind of whimsical angle when I read other news stories about various archaeological and historical discoveries. There’s always so much discussion on how a particular statue is “the cultural center of the community” or that a jeweled box was of “great religious significance”.

How do we know that the Elon Musk of 3000BC didn’t just build a big obelisk for the lulz?

Probably a bigger question of the problems of inferring great significance from extremely few samples...

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by mstade on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:51AM (#15969967)
I’ve thought the same. There are these rock carvings from forever ago around here, and whenever somebody visits who’s never seen something like that before I just say they are probably tweets from forever ago.

“This one over here is what someone had for lunch. I think ‘twas chicken.”

That sort of thing.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:54AM (#15969991)
I agree. On a related note, I still believe this to be most plausible explanation of the Voynich Manuscript:

https://xkcd.com/593/

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by IndrekR on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:43AM (#15969886)
My sources say that his Roadster is already orbiting the sun.

Mars would be a new thing. If this fails it will still be orbiting the sun, but as a distributed cluster this time.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by crispyambulance on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:27AM (#15969737)
Yep. He said "Mars transfer orbit."

I find it disappointing, however, that a worthy scientific payload isn't being launched. There was a late cancellation of a moon orbiter mission a few years back because of European Space Agency budget concerns (http://www.esa.int/Education/ESA_concludes_student_ESMO_Moon...). Could they not have adapted something for a Mars mission?

Seems a waste to send an automobile advertisement into orbit around Mars for eternity.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by indubitable on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:23AM (#15970291)
Do you know how much attention yet another orbiter would get? China literally landed on the moon -- the first time anything had soft landed on the moon in 37 years -- and they made some revolutionary discoveries. And nobody cared. Sending a car into orbit of Mars while literally playing Space Oddity, on loop - with a live stream available. That is something that would get massive coverage.

The coverage is not just an advertisement for SpaceX and Tesla, but for space in general. News has turned into sensationalistic drivel, driven by clicks than any sort of value. Little of what's seen on the news today will matter in 10 months, and you'd scarcely find a morsel that will matter in 10 years. This makes the absence of space coverage quite peculiar. 100 years, 100 centuries - the steps we are taking today, after a decades long haitus, into space will define the future we will all live in. If it takes being absurd to get peoples' attention in a world of clickbait, sensationalism, and drama - then, by all means, be absurd.

A big part of the reason it's difficult to get funding for space is because nobody cares. Oh look NASA's orbiter suggests our "recurring slope linaea", or RSL - an acronym more reminiscent of something a pharma ad suggested you may want to ask your doctor about than an unexplained phenomena that ought spark the imagination - may be water! How amazing is that! No, we have no real pictures and no.. we're not going to send the rover that direction.. and have no real plans to do so because of a 50 year old treaty. But think about it... in part because that's all anybody can do! Oh shit, another study just made a strong argument that the water is indeed just dust after all. Oh well. Maybe we just need another orbiter.

You're not sending an automobile into space, you're trying to capture and inspire the hearts and minds of the people. And not just the cliche nonsense of thinking of the children, but of all people. Because this experiment, if it succeeds, will probably have been the most interesting and exciting thing done in space in the past 40 years. Or we could beg for enough morsels to send another orbiter.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by greedo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:57AM (#15970630)
Considering the risk with this initial launch, short of a very low budget package, I think most researchers would prefer to wait for a safer launch.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by w8vY7ER on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:23AM (#15970938)
Prudence from greedo on the topic of first shots?
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by kodis on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:39AM (#15971111)
> I find it disappointing, however, that a worthy scientific payload isn't being launched.

It would also be disappointing if a worthy scientific payload were to be blown up on launch, an event which Musk seems to think is quite likely.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by jccooper on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:36PM (#15971769)
He's doing expectation management. If he thought it would fail they wouldn't fly.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by ogre_magi on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:33PM (#15972360)
I don't think this is true.

I think if Musk had to wager he'd bet that this launch is not completely successful. It still makes sense to fly it though. You hope to learn enough to make the second or third attempt a success.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by bryananderson on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:51PM (#15972548)
This isn’t necessarily true. They know that there are unknown unknowns at play here, as nothing quite like FH has ever flown. There is a non-negligible chance of something unforeseen rearing its ugly head, and if you’re just launching a lulz payload, that’s fine.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @07:33PM (#15975281)
The Roadster is the PR payload. The real payload is the set of all the sensors & transmitters in the rocket. They'll be getting a lot of engineering data whether it is a successful launch or not.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by crispyambulance on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @07:59PM (#15975433)
Yeah, of course, the main thing is to test the rocket and that's valuable by itself.

But still, couldn't there be SOMETHING more useful to mankind than a giant paperweight to send into orbit around Mars?

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by iamtew on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:57AM (#15970637)
They probably don't want to send expensive science payload on the first test flight of a new launch system, in case of catastrophic failure or such.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:07AM (#15970122)
>Seems a waste to send an automobile advertisement into orbit around Mars for eternity.

Especially since Red Bull will probably pay a lot of money to have a crash test dummy in a space suit strapped to a dirtbike with a Red Bull zip-tied into his hand, a GoPro on his helmet and some solar panels dangling somewhere broadcasting a live stream for the next handful of decades.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by jacquesm on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:30PM (#15972887)
Makes me wonder how well a Tesla Roadster would hold up when exposed to hard vacuum. They probably have a nice sized high vacuum chamber to put this to the test before they launch it.

Funny how this will probably be the best preserved Tesla Roadster in a couple of decades.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by JshWright on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:48AM (#15969409)
The first launch will be a "dummy" payload (nothing a customer is paying for). Elon has said on Twitter that they will be launching his Telsa Roadster out past Mars (there has been some discussion about how serious he was in this claim, but the general consensus among people who are pretty well connected with SpaceX is that he was indeed serious).
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by ufmace on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:38AM (#15969838)
You gotta wonder about that. I'd sure like to see some pictures of a Tesla Roadster being integrated into the payload section of the rocket.

On the mars orbit thing - I think we have people who try to make sure that we don't contaminate Mars with Earth bacteria any more than we can avoid. You would think people would take a dim view of sticking a random car in Mars orbit, where it will probably decay and crash to the surface eventually.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by d883kd8 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:58AM (#15970645)
It's not going to be in Mars orbit as there will be no insertion burn. It's a Mars flyby after which it will remain in solar orbit for the foreseeable future.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by sfifs on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:14PM (#15971516)
> I think we have people who try to make sure that we don't contaminate Mars with Earth bacteria any more than we can avoid.

Given Elon Musk's goal is explicitly to colonize Mars, this is probably the least of his worries.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by ufmace on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @07:03PM (#15975106)
That makes me wonder too - if he has the money and the rockets, can he just go ahead and set up a colony on Mars, or will some Government or combination of Governments object? Do the people of Earth generally have a right to have some level of say in who can set up a colony on Mars and what they can do with it, or can a couple of dozen rich guys just do whatever they feel like?
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by sfifs on Thursday December 21, 2017 @06:32PM (#15983925)
They can do pretty much what they want unless there is a political movement in multiple countries to stop it. In other words, there has to be profit for a bunch politicians to stop it or what they're doing has to be highly morally unpalatable. Given there is no apparent profit for Elon Musk in going to Mars in the first place, it's unlikely a bunch of politicians will find profit in stopping him. There's probably votes in smoothing things over for him because hope always wins more votes than negativity.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by _ph_ on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:52AM (#15969442)
The test itself is to launch the second stage towards the orbeit. The big question is, can they make the three cores work as well, as the single F9 core does?

As they have excessive load capacity for the second stage with this test mission, but no commecial cargo to transport, if Elons tweets are to believed, they plan to send his 2008 Tesla Roadster into a Mars orbit. Beyond winning any award for sillyness, if SpaceX manages to do that, it would be the first private mission to the Mars orbit, which would be another big feat.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by phpnode on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @08:48AM (#15969405)
They will launch Musk's Tesla Roadster into orbit around the sun, where it will continue orbiting for hundreds of millions of years.
Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by phkahler on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:30AM (#15969769)
>> They will launch Musk's Tesla Roadster into orbit around the sun, where it will continue orbiting for hundreds of millions of years.

Good god that's funny. I didn't realize the roadster was going anywhere, so it seemed stupid. But just imagine once people forget about this in 50 years. Perhaps we even have people on mars. But every few years someone post to the equivalent of HN a link to a wikipedia article about this car orbiting the sun... Or what if modern society suffers a setback (an actual nuclear war or something) and knowledge of this is forgotten and centuries hence, people redevelop technology and get images of it. Best joke ever.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by Banthum on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @09:38AM (#15969840)
Wouldn't be the first time we rediscovered something we shot out there and sorta forgot about.

If I recall correctly, a few years ago an astronomer detected something drifting pretty far away with weird visual characteristics. It turned out to be a big piece of metal discarded from one of the Apollo missions, painted white, still tumbling through space.

Re:SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy rocket sets up at Cape Canaveral ah... by indubitable on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @10:35AM (#15970409)
Or we succeed with the path we're starting to tread. And in less than a century there's a museum built around the car where people of all sorts, some perhaps even born on different planets, are free to visit and observe what would be utterly symbolic of the advent of private industry and deep space.