Re:Gerrymandering with geographically compact districts
by specialist on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:44PM
(#15972475)
I supported instant runoff voting until I figured out that it's difficult to explain, implement, audit. Pretty much all the reasons election administrators dislike it.
Approval Voting seems like the best compromise between fairness and simplicity (to better ensure election integrity).
Both scores and approvals are ambiguous in meaning and different people with the exact same preferences would map ballot papers differently. (In situations other than standard public elections, this may not be the case: approval is great for voting on group activities where either “approve” is a binding commitment to participate if the choice is chosen, or “disapprove” is a binding opt-out if the option is chosen.)