Re:The Screenless Office
by egwynn on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:41AM
(#15960910)
I'm seeing tons of comments about this thing being wasteful or impractical, as if these weren't specifically discussed in the source material. They were. They know. Here's their statement from the "Why" page:
[ Parent
| on HN ]
We can't comment on art? Can't lament its waste and implied value of the environment? Can't make suggestions on how a greater impact could be made (even if only to the commenter) with a few small tweaks, while still keeping the core values in place?
Sorry if it seems a bit snarky, but art is open to criticisms and critiques.
You can do of the above. Indeed, you personally did some of the above! Thanks! But many just came in and posted about it being wasteful and impractical, apparently unaware that the source material had already readily admitted as much about itself. To me, those comments don't add much to the conversation.
> ...poetic qualities instead of marketability.
Implying, of course, that comparable levels of usefulness are already established.
I will reserve my judgment until I see an actual practical demonstration that establishes that usefulness.
Re:The Screenless Office
by spaceseaman on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:59AM
(#15968079)
The statement assumes that one considers the poetic qualities as significant as marketability - not useful. You seem to have misunderstood the creators' intentions as they have no interest in providing you a "practical demonstration" or anything practical at all.
Art has little direct use - Michelangelo's David has very little practical value, yet it's significance is immense.
The creators of this project do not care for the practical value of any of this. They wish to experiment in the hope that some poetic qualities of their work will be deemed significant enough to carry on into new works (some of which may actually be useful).
> as they have no interest in providing you a "practical demonstration" or anything practical at all.
That was my exact understanding.
I'm not sure I know what you mean by "usefulness". I know that sounds weird, but they say they're not aiming to meet "standard principles of progress, universality and efficiency". So it sounds to me like the emotional/psychological impact on the user may be a higher priority for them than "good old fashioned productivity".