Git has eleventy million blog posts trying to explain how simple it is to use. That's a clear sign that it is, in fact, not simple or easy.
Unrelated topic (falling cats), same logical fallacy: http://www.radiolab.org/story/102525-vertigo/ (Starting around 14:20)
That should tell you something: these articles don’t resonate with the crowd. That should tell you something.
That's why I replied.
I can't really address p4 because I haven't used it for any real world use cases. Only to prepare for an interview. With that limited use, I can't come with any reason to think it's superior.
I made exactly one claim:
These git cheatsheets on how to get out of a bad state get a lot of traction on Hacker News. That is a pretty good indicator of something. Let's think about what that is. The fact that you consider it a serious indictment of git should also tell you something.
I'll make another claim now though:
When someone criticizes git, some users sure get defensive about it. That should also tell you something.
That Perforce and SVN don't get such things should also tell you something.
(Which isn't to hate on git--it's a great tool.)