Re:The rich are different from you and me
by isleyaardvark on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @11:35AM
(#1594974)
There could be an element of self-interest in poor people's support for charity:
> They found that both real lower-class participants and those temporarily induced to rank themselves as lower class felt that a greater share of a person’s salary should be used to support charity.
They could on some level see themselves as beneficiaries of charity, and be more charity-minded themselves to avoid cognitive dissonance.
Re:The rich are different from you and me
by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @02:34PM
(#1595584)
That's true, but it doesn't imply that charity is irrational.
If you derive utility from giving money to charity (e.g., you enjoy warm fuzzy feelings) then it is completely rational to do so. Charitable giving is a consumption good just like video games, playing soccer or shopping for clothes.
Re:The rich are different from you and me
by joshuacc on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @11:57AM
(#1595048)
Indeed but "economic rationality" is a narrow subset of rationality as a whole. And the lines I quoted above seemed to imply that charity is irrational, not just "economically irrational."
Re:The rich are different from you and me
by billybob on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @12:26PM
(#1595142)
Agreed - "economic rationality" is an extremely narrow concept. As an example, it's "rational" to buy yourself a car or an ice cream cone, because you get utility or enjoyment out of it. It's "irrational" to give money to others, because... you don't get enjoyment out of it? Wait, what if you do? A giant problem with the definition, methinks.
That's pretty much the definition of "rational" as it is applied in Economics. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_choice_theory