The tax system seems to prefer this to actually earning money for some reason.
The tax system favors unearned income over earned income to adjust for risk. If you work a job you're guaranteed to be paid for the hours you worked (assuming an honest employer). Investments have no guarantees and you could lose all the money you put in.
There's an argument to be made that the top tax rate for unearned income is too low in some countries, but it makes sense to me that the tax rate for unearned income should always be less than the tax rate for the same amount in earned income.
For example, the risk of losing an earned income stream because my (assumed honest) employer (fires me, goes bankrupt, etc.) seems much higher than the risk of losing an unearned income stream based on my investment in bonds backed by the US government.
Also since passive investment requires "no skill and little luck" it's one of the few entry routes into the capital-owning class available to working-class people and middle-class professionals. Anyone can buy an ETF for a couple hundred dollars. You don't need a hot stock tip or a insider lead on an undervalued property. So I'm not sure why one would want to start treating unearned income exactly the same as earned income at the precise point in history that we've learned about the magic of passive investment.
"Unearned income includes things like annuity payments, pension income, distributions from retirement accounts, capital gains, interest income, dividends, passive income generated from rental real estate, alimony, stock dividends, and bond interest." [2]
Sorry...is that what you meant? Or were you referring to the definition of earned income?
1. https://apps.irs.gov/app/IPAR/resources/help/unearn.html 2. https://www.thebalance.com/earned-income-is-taxed-differentl...
> investment in bonds backed by the US government.
Those bonds have a correspondingly low yield, to reflect their low risk.
Again, we can argue about how high the tax rate should be on unearned income vs earned income (20% max is too low IMO). But $50k in unearned income is worth less (risk-adjusted) than $50k in earned income and should accordingly be taxed lower. Maybe $50k in unearned income is the same as $20k in earned income and similarly all the way up the earnings ladder (I don't know the exact ratio; I made these numbers up).
We often talk about survivor bias in business success; how successful people owe something to luck as much as skill or hard work (which is true, IMO). Shouldn't the variance of this success be recognized in the tax code as well?
Well, yes, that's why the rewards of starting a business are often completely tax free up until a pretty high level. I don't really have a problem with that, which should have been pretty obvious from my above post.
However, that is completely irrelevant to what I said above.
Sitting on property and collecting rent is clearly not working.
>Again, we can argue about how high the tax rate should be on unearned income vs earned income
I'm of the opinion that unearned income should be taxed at 100% and distributed equally throughout the population whereas earned income should be taxed at 0%. I have yet to meet a person who can cogently argue why handouts (e.g. land rents) shouldn't be distributed equally.
Note that starting a business that grows is clearly earned at least up until a certain point (usually the point where the founder lets the employees run most things).
>Shouldn't the variance of this success be recognized in the tax code as well?
You really seem very keen on having the tax code encourage gambling over working.
I'm not so sure that using the tax code to deliberately discourage working for a living is necessarily the best way to generate a productive economy.
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree about that.
Even landlords have to work (and I say this as a tenant). There's tenants to screen, repairs to manage, regular safety inspections to perform. Land rents have volatility and risk as well. There's the possibility of vacancy or bad tenants which leaves you with a property that's not returning any value. A landslide could take away your property entirely and insurance won't cover it (don't scoff; I know someone this happened to). Maybe it's not as much work as running a small business, maybe it is, I don't know. But it's a non-zero amount of work.
EDIT: As I pointed out in a comment above, I think the top tax rate for unearned income should be higher, with more brackets overall. There's no reason for it to be flat 20% when the top rate for earned income is 40%. That unfairly penalizes small-time investors (who get taxed at 15% on an income that would be almost 0% if earned) as well as high-earning salaried people who pay 40% compared to the 20% someone making 20x as much in unearned income would pay.
> I have yet to meet a person who can cogently argue why handouts (e.g. land rents) shouldn't be distributed equally.
Taxing rental income at 100% would kill off the rental market completely. A lot of people like the flexibility of renting and don't want to deal with realtors and banks and mortgages every time they change their job. Many people can't afford the down payment to buy a house so they need to rent until they've saved up enough to do so (you might argue that property prices will go down because of no landlords and there won't be a need for mortgages, not sure that'll actually happen but it's another topic). Businesses also rent offices or retail space when they can't or don't need to buy. At the end of the day, landlords provide a service that's useful, by deploying their capital and labor.
> I'm of the opinion that unearned income should be taxed at 100%
Here's the IRS definition of unearned income:
"Unearned income includes investment-type income such as taxable interest, ordinary dividends, and capital gain distributions."[1]
So if you really mean that, you're going to be taxing average-Joe-worker-with-index-funds (that includes me BTW) 100% on his dividends. Maybe we need to start being clear on what the term "unearned income" really means before we argue further :-)
1. https://apps.irs.gov/app/IPAR/resources/help/unearn.html
> whereas earned income should be taxed at 0%
So...CEO making $50 million/year would pay $0 in taxes?
> You really seem very keen on having the tax code encourage gambling over working.
Gambling implies the possibility of loss, the presence of real risk. And even property speculation is still a lot of work; you have to research lots and lots of properties, crunch numbers, line up funding, develop and market the property for rent or resale. Given that it's work with more risk involved than taking a paycheck, why is it a bad thing for the tax code to recognize this?
So long as you have a good financial advisor you're estate will go up in value over time.
??
Who gets to determine who deserves what?
Determining someone's future on parental wealth means determining someone's future on a lack of parental wealth - and a vast majority of parents don't have meaningful wealth.
So we're (society is at present) consigning a majority of children to a life of missed opportunity and missed potential. I don't see how that can be a good thing.
Also, parental wealth doesn't "determine their future" any more than the quality of the parents does. It's certainly a leg up, all else being equal, but it's very possible to live an enjoyable and fulfilling life without much wealth if you're willing to get outside of the focus on consumption, and personally, I'd generally take poor, loving parents over rich, uncaring/selfish/narcissistic parents.
Who you're born to will always be a lottery that leaves winners and losers, even if everyone is equally wealthy. You'll get variable quality genetics, if nothing else, at least until we completely master human genetic engineering.
There's still the option of living a comfortable life being totally unproductive - but why let that option waste an unnecessary amount of our society's assets?
This would be an extremely strong move by the government, you're right, but I think most people would be behind it, especially since it would affect less than a percent of the population. We're not headed down that path currently, but I thought it was an idea worth sharing.
Most productive parents are already highly incentivized to not see their children become totally unproductive wastrels, because the culture that made them productive taught them to value productivity, and good parents typically want to see their children instilled with what they see as good values. I don't think the government needs to do much more there.
> There's still the option of living a comfortable life being totally unproductive - but why let that option waste an unnecessary amount of our society's assets?
There are a couple things to unpack here. First off, wealthy peoples' wealth doesn't just sit in a cave, it's almost always ~100% invested in productive ventures. Even sitting in the bank, the bank is using it to write loans to people and businesses to do things with.
The other thing is that it's part of our very basic social compact that peoples' property is theirs and their family's, not the society's, and only in very limited circumstances can the government/society seize that property for the use of the group.
An exceptionally productive individual can generate billions, but then when he dies the money goes to his heirs which may not have done anything to deserve commanding that much wealth other than having been raised by (and having the genetics of) the exceptionally productive individual, which is a far cry from being exceptionally productive themselves.
My thought was to create a cap on inheritance. Enough so that the heirs would be able to live a normal middle class life without working, but not be disgustingly wealthy like the parent. ~$5 million seemed like enough to live off interest for a lifetime. I don't think productivity would be disincentivized too much by this, as the productive individuals still get to use their wealth as long as they're living. It'd probably be pretty difficult to plug all the loopholes but I think it's worth thinking about.
edit: another thing, we could lighten some other taxes (income, property, whatever) for this increased death tax such that the overall government tax income remains roughly the same, to make the proposal more palatable. Overall, everyone keeps more of their wealth, and the playing field is leveled and we're a bit closer to an actual meritocracy.