News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox is on a slippery slope by mulmen on Saturday December 16, 2017 @05:27PM (#15942565)
> The one thing I know is that I am writing from a Firefox right now and don't see headers, inversions etc. at all. The examples given in the article should have all been inverted, right?

"It involved sideloading a sketchy browser extension which will invert text that matches a list of Mr. Robot-related keywords like “fsociety”, “robot”, “undo”, and “fuck”, and does a number of other things like adding an HTTP header to certain sites you visit."

Only if HN is on the list of "certain sites". It's also irrelevant because the extension offers me no value so Mozilla was not acting in my best interest.

Re:Firefox is on a slippery slope by ifdefdebug on Saturday December 16, 2017 @06:10PM (#15942800)
OK, so I got that wrong with the "certain sites".

But still, the fact that the extension was not active unless you mess around in about:config is a crucial fact, which should not have been omitted in an highly critical article, specially if they use words like "Mozilla, you fucked up bad, and you still haven’t apologised. The study is still active and ongoing".

I feel misinformed by that article, to say the less.

Re:Firefox is on a slippery slope by fanon on Saturday December 16, 2017 @07:34PM (#15943173)
> Only if HN is on the list of "certain sites".

If that is the case (I'm not saying it's not, just that I don't know)... why did the extension even need to exist? Presumably "certain sites" are partner sites participating in the promotion. If they are participating and (I assume) they control their own content, why didn't they just invert those words or whatever else they wanted to do with the content when they served it?

I'm very confused about why this needed to roll out as a browser extension at all.

Re:Firefox is on a slippery slope by Zarel on Saturday December 16, 2017 @11:40PM (#15944147)
The articles on this whole controversy describe it as an ARG - an Alternate Reality Game. I don't know exactly how this ARG works, but ARGs in general are like scavenger hunts - players investigate what's causing the changes, which give them hints as to where to look next.

So presumably it was implemented as a browser extension so game players would be able to find the browser extension, which would give them hints about what to do next.