So if you don't make a profit from a crime, you shouldn't be punished for that crime?

That's like saying if I attempt to steal something from a store, security stops me, retrieves the item, then I shouldn't be punished because I didn't get anything from my crime, in fact it cost me money, in gas, going to the store to steal from it...

The "they were defrauding us too" is a weaselly argument - it can be argued that when you are an executive, you represent the company, and directing people to do something, can they really be said to be deceiving/defrauding you by _doing as you directed_?