News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by davidw on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:49PM (#15924462)
You can't undo net neutrality without putting in place some serious and real competition though, otherwise it's not going to work. Most people have only 1 or maybe 2 broadband providers available.
Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by criddell on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:02PM (#15924646)
I totally expect that the next administration will create new regulations. Then the next administration will remove them. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by pythonaut_16 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:22PM (#15924910)
Could we create a self-regulating internet? One where the desired outcome of Net Neutrality is ensured by the protocol itself? What would it take?

I know there are projects like IPFS and Zeronet, but I don't think any of them are targeted specifically at avoiding throttling based on source/destination pair.

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by criddell on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:03PM (#15927581)
So if ISPs are using deep packet inspection to figure out what you are doing to apply some prioritization to your traffic, then using a VPN is a way of hiding that from them. All they would see is a stream of random data flying by. The pessimist in me says they would probably start slowing all encrypted traffic and sell their own VPN service.
Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by wooter on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:41PM (#15925268)
because no one wants that. the overhead of those guarantees makes no sense given the diversity of protocols the "internet" is meant to create. people would just use faster protocols for their intended purposes. the beauty is that the degree of Net Neutrality that we do have was created with minimal regulation before 2015. Risking further regulatory capture now, given the issues with local isp monopolies, makes no sense.
Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by r00fus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:03PM (#15924660)
Sure you can - if the intent is to destroy the free Internet that exists now.

Follow the money.

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by X86BSD on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:54PM (#15924524)
Agreed. It’s mostly one land based provider and maybe a satellite option.

You know I would almost be willing to consider scrapping NN if they also had the power to overturn and throw out ALL incumbent laws preventing competition from accessing right of ways, street and utility poles and making it so easy to bury cable you could do it in your sleep at state/city/local levels.

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by rayiner on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:07PM (#15924724)
> overturn and throw out ALL incumbent laws preventing competition from accessing right of ways, street and utility poles and making it so easy to bury cable you could do it in your sleep at state/city/local levels.

Let's not forget all the laws requiring fledgling ISPs to build out to entire cities, instead of focusing on areas where they might be able to quickly start turning a profit. Even if you have net neutrality, these laws are still preventing you from getting faster and better options for internet.

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by X86BSD on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:15PM (#15924822)
Agreed. The regulations we both mentioned have killed any competition in providing, let’s just call internet connection providers what they are, dumb pipes. That’s what they all boil down to. Just dumb pipes to give you access to a network.

And in that context the more providers of dumb pipes we have the better. It’s just a race to the bottom then. Who offers the lowest latency, highest speed and capacity pipe for the cheapest price.

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by wooter on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:35PM (#15925160)
the problem is politicians (mostly local) who sell municipal monopolies in exchange for donations at a time when other parts of the world allow multiple companies to build/lease the dumb pipes to great success (like South Korea). its pure corruption. thats why places like florida (the sunshine state) don't use solar. Government backed monopolies.

we should be investigating these corrupt arrangements (given that the existence of obviously better options suggests fraud and abuse) and forcing the government to undo its shitty decisions. (buy back/sell if necessary) the opposite would be to submit the internet to regulatory capture under NN and the FCC (which effectively killed TV and radio - forcing private cable and streaming content creators to give us the few uncensored options we DO have)

Re:Vice News FCC Net Neutrality Vote Live Stream by merb on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:46PM (#15925345)
well... I've never been in USA but you must have really great streets. but a lot of streets are already painful to use. and if every internet company could dig holes and put their cabeles in, it would probably be even worse. I mean in germany it's common that the street gets opened 3-4 times. 1. to repair/create it 2. to repair/add everything to do with water 3. to repair/add electricity 4. to repair/add networking/telecom

why? because most often they unify themself, because everybody said that they should pay less, because they do not do much... It happens way too often here. I'm just 27 years old and I already seen it many times a year. this year was especially painful. I've seen streets completly remade - and then after finishing it they opened it again and again 1 month past finish

yes it might probably help the competition. but it could make other things worse. I think land-lines, water, electricity should be in the hands of govt. or some kind of foundatition that manages these things in a escrow fashion and everybody could get a piece if he pays x % for x% of usage.