News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by laGrenouille on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:55AM (#15922242)
The problem with this argument is that there is no particular "they" that lied here. George Bush (senior) negotiated these assurances and then, almost a decade later, Clinton reneged on them.

I think it is generally known that foreign relation promises not enshrined in formal treaties should not be expected to last across different administrations.

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by Spooky23 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @09:48AM (#15922614)
Another important distinction is that they made an assurance to the Soviet Union, not Russia.

The political situation in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet republics changed pretty substantially as well.

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by sebasmurphy on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:23AM (#15922933)
+1. I fail to see how the NATO is in the 'wrong' here. They broke assurances in 1994 that they made to an entity which failed to exist after 1991. WUT?
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by mantas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:38AM (#15923070)
Just Russia being Soviet Union successor when it's convenient and claiming to be a new state when it's not.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by Spooky23 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:28AM (#15923548)
Russia yearns for the good old days.

Russia isn’t the Soviet Union, it was a part of the Soviet Union, and a member of the “Commonwealth of Independent States” that nominally succeeded it. My understanding is that treaties were reaffirmed with the individual states.

Does every non-binding commitment to be Soviet Union apply to Uzbekistan? Estonia? Georgia?

What about when the desires of Estonia conflict with the Soviets?

What about when the interests of the United States and other big NATO states conflict with the commitments to the various Post-Soviet states?

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by mantas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @03:49PM (#15926875)
Yet Russia took Soviet Union embassies. Even those that belonged to other countries before USSR annexed them. As well as grandfathered USSR seat in UN security council.

Kaliningrad was also given to Soviet Union Even though it was attached to Russian Federation to work around this. If Russia ain't Soviet Union successor, Kaliningrad should be no man's land or returned to Germany.

Talking about Estonia.. When Estonia tried to relocate USSR monument, it was Russia which objected.

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by chokolad on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:47AM (#15923814)
> Russia yearns for the good old days.

Russia picked up all the Soviet Union debt obligations. All those successor states have been essentially debt free on day one.

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by gandhium on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:32PM (#15924278)
They _tricked_ others to take debt obligations for themselves. Since they took _all_ the Soviet properties as well.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by chokolad on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:56PM (#15925523)
That's _novel_ interpretation of that deal.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by Giorgi on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:46PM (#15928836)
Yet, that's exactly what happened and you "conveniently" forgot to mention that Russia also took all the SU wealth and reserves. They even pulled back all of the weapons and military vehicles out of the ex-member countries, leaving them exposed and then started to help separatists in the wars against sovereign nations. Russia is shittiest neighbor of them all.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by chokolad on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:46AM (#15923794)
Can you provide an example of Russia denying Soviet Union's obligations when it was not convenient?
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by gandhium on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:43PM (#15924392)
Accepting blame for Soviet occupation of Baltic states or Poland. Accepting repercussions for Holodomor.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by chokolad on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:55PM (#15925515)
Soviet Union did not accept the blame for occupation of Baltic states so I don't see how it should be Russia's obligation.

Repercussions of Holodomor were deaths of millions of Soviet citizens in Russia, Kazakhstan, Ukraine and Belarus. What do you want Russia to accept here ?

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by mantas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @03:44PM (#15926831)
Russia denies it's Soviet Union obligations whenever talks turn to paying reparations for Baltic States occupation or military actions in Czechoslovakia or Hungary.

Yet they love Soviet Union obligations when they don't return Lithuania's interwar embassy in Rome. Or when May 8/9 comes around :)

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by gandhium on Friday December 15, 2017 @12:12PM (#15933246)
> Soviet Union did not accept the blame for occupation of Baltic states so I don't see how it should be Russia's obligation.

USSR didn't accept 'Tsar's bonds' yet Russia payed them out.

So, yeah, double standards.

> What do you want Russia to accept here

Same as for praising 'Russian' victory over Germany, for example. Accept their involvement.

Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:25AM (#15923509)
Exactly, much of the eastward expansion of NATO was from parts of the Soviet Union joining NATO. If they didn't want NATO to expand eastward, then they shouldn't have joined it.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by chokolad on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:45AM (#15923775)
The problem is, that when Russia brought up those agreements pretty much everybody said "nu-uh, that did not happen, show me the agreements". When Russians mention that the agreement was verbal they are pretty much accused of lying. Now we have proof that the verbal agreement exists.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by Giorgi on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:51PM (#15928860)
The problem is, agreement was made with Soviet Union and not with Russia.
Re:Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past Eas... by Jesus_Jones on Friday December 15, 2017 @08:03PM (#15936680)
it isn't a binding agreement if there is no treaty. I'm sure russia had some treaties saying don't invade georgia, but they did. The old soviet union gave Crimea to Ukraine and Russia took it back by force. That was part of another country.

Russia's violates treaties when it wants. It is not a trustworthy country. I think Russia is afraid of countries that want to be independent of the Russia's greater power.