Re:Why you should go to jail for videotaping police officers
by anigbrowl on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @01:06PM
(#1592208)
Yes, somewhat. It's pretty easy to tell if something has been edited. All but the most expensive professional cameras compress the video they record and editing leaves 'fingerprints' in the file. On cheaper cameras like cellphones, the lens is so cheap and compression so brutal that the images are pretty noisy, and the noise is actually an aid in this because sudden discontinuities are a giveaway that something has been doctored.
These three individuals are really sounding like parodies of themselves, essentially claiming that only evidence they collect is admissible. By that standard, defense attorneys in criminal cases should never be allowed to submit evidence, because anything not coming from the police could be fake. In any case, the court is the trier of fact, not the DA or the officer on the street.
Police officers and prosecutors do a necessary, but often unpleasant and dangerous job, with a complex mix of responsibilities and liabilities. I don't like to stereotype them any more than I do poor people or even criminals. But when they offer such nakedly self-serving arguments designed to bypass critical thinking, I want to see them out on their ass ASAP - it does a disservice to all the dedicated individuals who serve with integrity.
These three individuals are really sounding like parodies of themselves, essentially claiming that only evidence they collect is admissible. By that standard, defense attorneys in criminal cases should never be allowed to submit evidence, because anything not coming from the police could be fake. In any case, the court is the trier of fact, not the DA or the officer on the street.
Police officers and prosecutors do a necessary, but often unpleasant and dangerous job, with a complex mix of responsibilities and liabilities. I don't like to stereotype them any more than I do poor people or even criminals. But when they offer such nakedly self-serving arguments designed to bypass critical thinking, I want to see them out on their ass ASAP - it does a disservice to all the dedicated individuals who serve with integrity.