News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by gjm11 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @12:32PM (#1592066)
Most interesting sentence, to me: The median income in 2008 was below what it was in 1998.

GDP in 2008 surely isn't below what it was in 1998.

What we're seeing here is yet another indication of the big increase in inequality in the US over recent years.

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @01:44PM (#1592329)
Or debt-fueled spending has been adding to GDP between 1998 and 2008. Did we by any chance have a massive debt fueled speculative bubble from 1998 to 2007?

(If you borrow $10 and spend it, GDP has increased by $10. If you spend it on something other than services, income won't go up commensurately.)

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by roc on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:35PM (#1592501)
It can be both; and almost certainly is.

GDP growth has been inflated by debt-fueled spending.

But the change in inequality stems largely from globalization applying downward pressure on wages.

Simply: 10, 20, or 30 years ago, more of the component cost of a product went into middle and lower class wages. Now, wages are down; more-so for industries where costs are easier to optimize globally.

Protectionism was the wrong conclusion, but labor had it exactly right when they posited that buying lower-cost goods (those with costs sourced internationally) would squeeze the income of the working class. There's no way it couldn't.

(What labor glossed over, is that stagnant wages don't necessarily mean stagnant quality of life. But they were organizations rewarded only for increasing wages, so they predictably had no interest in the larger objective view.)

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by earl on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:13PM (#1592660)
It is not true that changes in inequality stem from globalization.

Changes in inequality stem from political decisions about the allocation of income increases.

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by roc on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @11:52AM (#1595026)
Political decision by whom?
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by cynicalkane on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:14PM (#1592431)
?

Every payment is a transfer from one person to another. If you spend $10 on, say, golden rocks (gold), it doesn't get eaten and wiped from existence by the God of Golden Rocks, but rather goes into the pocket of the gold miners and owners of the gold mining capital. It doesn't make a difference that gold is a commodity, not a service.

Net product is equal to income. You learn this in Macroeconomics 101. Example financial statement: http://www.bea.gov/national/nipaweb/TableView.asp?SelectedTa...

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:38PM (#1592515)
I believe gjm11 was talking about personal income (i.e., wages/tips/capital gains), not total income to all entities. At least, that's usually what people talking about inequality are discussing, since that's the only thing the government keeps statistics on.

So buying $10 worth of golden rocks will increase GDP by $10, and the balance sheet of Gold Inc by $10. This will only increase personal income if the owner of Gold Inc sells $10 worth of stock or receives $10 worth of dividends in the same year.

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by cynicalkane on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:42PM (#1592534)
This could be true, but I find it more likely that the original poster simply doesn't understand what he's talking about. For example, take your thought experiment, and modify it such that Gold, Inc. pays out all $10 in compensation and dividends, and grows its balance sheet by $0.

Now, we have $10 in debt-fueled spending, $10 in increased personal income, and the original poster is still wrong.

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by gjm11 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @06:10PM (#1593118)
I fail to see how your criticisms indicate that I simply don't understand what I'm talking about, though of course that's always possible.

Aggregate personal income is typically roughly proportional to GDP. GDP has grown quite a bit over the last decade, which suggests that aggregate personal income has too. The population hasn't grown much over that time, which suggests that mean personal income has also grown quite a bit. (More quantitatively: US GDP growth has been something like 40% per decade recently, US population growth more like 10%, so mean income has grown by about 30% over that period.)

If median income goes down and mean income goes up, that typically indicates that richer people are gaining while poorer people lose. (It doesn't have to; imagine, e.g., that everyone below the median income jumps to $1/year below the median. Result: the median stays the same while the mean goes up. This is not at all what typically happens, though.)

If the growth in aggregate personal income has been slower than that in GDP, that indicates that businesses' profits are growing faster than what they pass on to their employees. That translates in the not-much-longer term to more money for the owners of the businesses. Who are, surprise surprise, on average substantially wealthier than median. So, again, more gains for the wealthy than for the not-so-wealthy; so, again, increasing inequality.

What any of this has to do with the bizarre notion that when you buy gold the money gets eaten by a golden rock god, I'm not sure. (I can kinda see how you might have got the impression that yummyfajitas thinks that, but immediately after making the golden-rock-god comment it seems like you start speculating on how I probably have no clue what I'm talking about. Highly mysterious, but I'm probably just being dim.)

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by cynicalkane on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @12:23AM (#1593820)
I mistakenly thought both posts made by Mr. yummyfajitas were made by two different people. Sorry about the confusion.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by gjm11 on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @07:24AM (#1594385)
Aha, understood. I hadn't appreciated that, and hence thought that when you said "the OP" you meant me rather than yummyfajitas. Sorry for getting confused.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by oconnore on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @07:17PM (#1593245)
I don't think cynicalkane was responding directly to you.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by eru on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:20PM (#1592444)
A side note: While Gold is chemically fairly stable, money can be created and destroyed.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by cynicalkane on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:33PM (#1592493)
I'm confused what this has to do with the national income and product accounts. The point of my post is that any product produced and traded falls on both sides of the product/income balance. If a gold miner decides to eat that dollar later (or sell it to the Federal Reserve) that's a monetary phenomenon.

My guess is that you wanted to throw out some vaguely gold-bug sort of thing out there, and protect yourself from downvoting by marking it "side note".

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by eru on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @08:35PM (#1593407)
Please let me explain. I do not really disagree with your main points.

yummyfajitas comment about only expenses on services showing up in income was probably not very well worded. I guess he's not using the economist's definition of income. If you substitute wages for `income' in his statement, it makes some sense.

Also I do see that income and production have to be equal (modulo effects of moving wealth in and out of the system, perhaps). Different consumption patterns may lead to different distributions of income and wages, even if the sum stays the same.

(I don't know whether `the debt fuelled boom' that was mentioned, depresses the median income while boosting the rich.)

My side note was really just a side note. The central bank does create and destroy money. I am not a gold bug. If you want commodity based money, tie your currency to a basket of commodities. Even the BigMac index is better than useless gold.

Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by eru on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @01:39PM (#1595381)
P.S. I only mentioned gold because you mention gold.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by chc on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @12:45PM (#1592121)
Or more of our GDP is going overseas rather than into American pockets. Or more money is being taken up by various sources of financial friction (taxes, fees businesses need to pay, etc.). Or all three.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by cynicalkane on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:24PM (#1592451)
I'd like to see a new feature on Hacker News that attaches a [citation needed] to all economic posts. We are actually getting more income from foreign countries than they are getting from us: http://www.bea.gov/national/nipaweb/TableView.asp?SelectedTa... .
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by chc on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:01PM (#1592605)
I hope you aren't suggesting my comment needs a citation, since it was merely making a claim of possibility. The parent of my comment looked at some data and drew a conclusion, and I was replying that the data could lend itself just as well to other interpretations and thus we can't draw such a strong conclusion. Hence the repeated use of the word "or" rather than "THESE ARE THE FACTS AND I AM A LEADING ECONOMIST SO YOU BELIEVE THIS IS ALL TRUE."
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by francoisdevlin on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:06PM (#1592400)
Or bad math. The guy confuses mean & median in the article.
Re:Is Any Job Better Than No Job? by motters on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:50PM (#1592568)
GDP per capita has increased linearly in the US over the last few decades.

http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs217.snc4/39207...

The distribution of salaries for the UK looks like this:

http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs224.snc4/38561...

and I expect that the US is even more extreme, although I don't have any data for US salaries.