News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @11:40PM (#15919992)
Some comments about the article and Chinese fighter development- some of these points mentioned in the article but glossed over, some are implied but not mentioned, and some completely absent:

1. Stealth for fighters isn't about keeping the enemy from seeing you entirely. That went away a long time ago. Stealth helps your survivability by making it take a little longer for you to be seen. If you can see the enemy from 50 miles away, but they can't see you until 20 miles away then you have a huge advantage in being able to launch a missile first.

2. Stealth is not just about RF, it's about visual and thermal cues too. The latest generation of missiles are going to multi-mode seekers (RF + IR is one possibility) so you need stealth in multiple domains to be effective.

3. RF stealth can only be optimized for one band. So you might design your coatings and structures to work against X-band (10GHz-ish) but be effectively 4th-gen non-stealth against early warning recievers that operate in the MHz range and against short range radar in the Ka-band (40 GHz-ish). This is why point 1 has become the way it is. The enemy will know you're there.

4. China is great at some areas, and laughably bad at others. They haven't put the WS-15 engine on the J-20 yet because they don't know how to make it right. They are currently spending tons of money on researching metallurgy so they can catch up with the rest of the developed world. It's funny that they can develop their own advanced radar and jammers but they still have to buy all their engines from Russia.

5. Good missiles are a huge component in survivability- a long range missile with lock on after launch capability can be fired in "the general direction" of a target without you having to have your own lock on them. This is good if you have an X-band radar on your jet but can get cues from a surveillance radar in another band, and your missile seeker is also in another band. This means your weak point that the enemy stealth was optimized for is covered by the strengths of your other air power. China makes great missiles.

6. Command, Control, and Communication (and Cyber, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) play a huge part in a major air battle. It's not just a bunch of individuals trying to get their guy, but a coordinated strategy. China is especially dependent on control and communication, since their pilots are trained to follow orders from the ground. You need jam-resistant communications for this. China is great with RF stuff.

7. The article claims jets like the J-11 are 3rd gen equivalent and J-20 are 4th gen equivalent. This is almost surely an intentional downgrade because if this D.C. based think tank revealed what they actually thought it might hint that they know more about these jets than they want to. Calling a J-11 a 3rd gen is laughable. The latest J-11B is basically 4.5 gen. It can match or even outperform a fully upgraded F-15C in many areas. While it may not be better overall than a F-15C, it is at least 4th gen, call it 4.25 gen to a new F-15C's 4.5 gen. The same goes for the J-20, it is clearly better than 4th gen, call it 4.9 gen to the F-22's 5th gen.

8. While a J-20 might not match a F-22 one-on-one, if they can make the J-20 en masse, they will present a serious threat to the F-22. We only built 187 F-22s, haven't fully upgraded all of them (some don't need upgrading since they are only used for training), have crashed a few, and cannabalized others for parts. We'd be lucky to get 100 fully upgraded F-22s to a fight. We're hoping that we can make enough F-35s to cover that small number, but China is making the J-31 to counter.

In conclusion- Does China's J-20 rival other stealth fighters? Yes. Maybe they aren't fully competing in the stealth category, but you should be afraid of it because it has other strengths.

Edit: Danm, I almost forgot about electronic warfare (EW). Another alternative to stealth is jamming the other guy's ears off. It makes you vulnerable to anti-radiation missiles, but missile launch detection and a good on/off switch makes jamming a great self-protection scheme. Coherent distributed jamming is on the horizon, possibly to the point of fooling anti radiation missiles. China's pretty good at EW, just like they are at radar and communication stuff. The next all out war where developed countries throw all of their technology at each other is going to suck.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by jacquesm on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:48AM (#15920220)
To your point '4':

"China is great at some areas, and laughably bad at others. They haven't put the WS-15 engine on the J-20 yet because they don't know how to make it right. They are currently spending tons of money on researching metallurgy so they can catch up with the rest of the developed world. It's funny that they can develop their own advanced radar and jammers but they still have to buy all their engines from Russia."

It wasn't all that long ago that Russia had the drop on just about everybody in the world including the USA when it came to Titanium processing. They quite possibly still do. It's not rare at all to see a country be 'great in some areas, laughably bad in others', this is simply a reflection of their investment into that particular tech to date. And if China has so far proven one thing it is that they are pretty good at catching up.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @02:44AM (#15920603)
You're right about the history and every country will have their own strengths and weaknesses, but there's a difference between Russia being one step ahead of several countries and China being several steps behind several countries. Russia is singularly good at something, while China is singularly bad. The top student in a class typically doesn't laugh when everyone is worse than them, but the entire class often laughs at the one student that still can't grasp what everyone else understands, and has for a while. In this case the class is the countries with a permanent seat on the UN security council.

China didn't realize how far behind they were at metallurgy until they tried making jet engines. Jet engines are complex, so we weren't surprised the first time a domestic Chinese engine sucked. Not surprised about the second engine sucking either. But it's kind of funny now seeing as they still haven't gotten the hang of it.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by jacquesm on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:18AM (#15922881)
There also was a time when Russia (and Germany) were well ahead of the United States in terms of access to space.

I would expect China to take as long or shorter than it took the rest of the countries that mastered that particular skillset. Incidentally, I had a tour of the company that makes the machines that mill the final contours of those turbine blades and I'm not at all surprised that this is extremely complex knowledge, I know quite a bit about CNC machining and they managed to surprise me more than I had expected possible.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by justicezyx on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:13AM (#15920102)
> China is especially dependent on control and communication, since their pilots are trained to follow orders from the ground.

Not sure where this idea comes from. Air combat cannot be commanded. Or you mean something else.

> The article claims jets like the J-11 are 3rd gen equivalent and J-20 are 4th gen equivalent.

US has 4-gen division, Russia uses 5 gen division. China uses the same categorization as US, so J20 is 4th-gen, j-11 is gen 3.

Russian and India likes to use the 5-gen categorization, to some extent, that makes Russian fighters looks nicer.

[edit] The article actually use 5-gen categorization but list j-11 as gen 3... I have no idea how these people still have their jobs...

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:49AM (#15920409)
> Not sure where this idea comes from. Air combat cannot be commanded. Or you mean something else.

Obviously nobody commands the entire fight since the enemy also gets a say in what happens.

What I meant is that Chinese pilots are trained to take direction from ground controllers that are looking at the integrated air picture from all of their surveillance systems. It's called ground controlled intercept (GCI). China and the former Soviet Union countries are heavily reliant on GCI. The idea is that the pilot is busy flying the plane and can't see the integrated picture in the cockpit, so a person on the ground that can see the full picture and isn't distracted by flying can make better tactical decisions about which targets to engage, when to shoot, and when to go out (turn away). A Chinese pilot hears on the radio "Callsign, turn to heading 170, Mach 0.9, target 5 miles" and doesn't know what else is going on around him. The GCI style gets severely degraded when communications go down, because the pilots lose the guidance in their ear.

The comparison is that western pilots are told what the air picture looks like and then the formation commander decides who to target. Western pilots hear "Hostiles at x position, y position, and z position" and then mutually decide who each person is going to target based on contracts (they pre-decided on the ground that #1 and #2 in formation get the northern target and #3 and #4 get the southern target, whoever is done first gets the trailing target) and then listening to the formation commander to catch any mistakes. It's complicated for the pilots but works better when communications go down.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by Teever on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:16AM (#15921988)
It seems like the Chinese/Russian technique would work better over their own territory and therefore implies that it's a technique developed from a defensive strategy.

Is this a reasonable characterization?

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by hangonhn on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:37AM (#15920179)
I can't speak for the original poster but both Chinese and Russian tactics have in the past largely depended heavily on ground based guidance. This is partly the reason for or perhaps because of their planes having inferior radar or none at all in some cases. This was the case during the Cold War. Things might have change since then. Perhaps this is where we get the notion that Chinese pilots are trained to strictly follow orders from the ground.
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by rajathagasthya on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:45AM (#15920393)
Lockheed advertises F-22 and F-35 as 5th generation fighters. Does the USAF have a different terminology?
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by dingaling on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:05AM (#15920269)
> It's funny that they can develop their own advanced radar and jammers but they still have to buy all their engines from Russia.

How is that 'funny'? There are five nations on Earth that can design modern aircraft high-powered jet engines from scratch:

USA, UK, France, China, Russia.

Six if we include India which does so with French and US assistance. The fact that China is able to play in that league is impressive in itself, even if they are the weakest player.

Everyone else is nowadays confined to licensed production or a lower tier of performance.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by kuschku on Thursday December 14, 2017 @02:28AM (#15920549)
Splitting UK/France off from other parts of western Europe doesn't make that much sense, though, considering how in the past decades R&D has been distributed over the continent, as has manufacturing.
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by kss238 on Thursday December 14, 2017 @02:08AM (#15920476)
Am I missing something here about point 7?

>It is worth noting, however, that China’s criteria for defining aircraft generations differs from accepted international standards. China defines aircraft generations based upon when an aircraft was integrated into the air force. Per China’s criteria, the J-20 is considered a fourth-generation aircraft.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @02:23AM (#15920531)
You're right, I misread the table. I thought they were claiming that aircraft in the same row had similar capabilities. I can't seem to edit my original comment since it's been too long.
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by deepnotderp on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:20AM (#15920127)
You seem knowledgeable, so I'll ask you this: what're the prospects for bistatic radar detecting stealth aircraft?
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:29AM (#15920352)
Stealth works in two ways: absorption and scattering. Absorption works by soaking up some of the RF energy, but is limited. Effectively absorbing the RF is limited by physics, since you can't put a 20 cm thick coating on a plane and expect it to fly.

Scattering works by keeping the RF from being reflected back to the transmitter, which is also the receiver in a monostatic design. If you can stick a receiver into the path of scattered energy, you can theorectically detect it.

However, there are some issues to overcome to make a good multistatic system. Scattering disperses the energy, so it's not like the receivers are getting a particularly strong signal, so you need a big high gain antenna. That's easier for the home team playing defense, but kind of hard for an attacker who has to stay portable. Then you also have to overcome the communication issues. Radar requires precise timing, which is easier when the transmitter and receiver are right next to each other. You can send a precision timing signal over large distances (precision timing is one of the reasons that GPS exists, as well as Europe's, China's, and Russia's versions), but you have to actually take the theory of relativity into account when designing the system- clearly not impossible, it just makes the math a smidgen harder. You also have to control the real estate to put multiple antennas out there. You also have to get your receiver into the path of the scattered energy, so you are SOL if your receiver is on the ground and the stealth plane is scattering all the RF upwards (unless you have antennas in space...).

Multistatic systems are feasible and operational versions already exist. But there are enough tradeoffs that traditional monostatic systems aren't going anywhere. A good defense would use a bistatic system as one of the many layers of surveillance.

Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by hangonhn on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:40AM (#15920192)
That pretty much has to work, right? If your transmitter and receiver are set far apart, anything that interrupts the transmission will cue someone to an object being in between. But I wonder how practical that is.
Re:Does China’s J-20 rival other stealth fighters? by olympus on Thursday December 14, 2017 @01:57AM (#15920442)
Interrupting the signal isn't how multistatic radar works. You actually get two signals, the first is the transmission that traveled in a straight line to get there, the second is the one that bounced off the plane and took a little longer to get there. By measuring the time delay you know how much longer two legs of the triangle are from the third. By doing this with multiple receivers you can solve a system of equations to figure out where the plane is. Solving the system of equations to make all the triangles work out is why it's called triangulation.