By way of an understanding of human nature. From the book Bull! A history of boom and bust:
“...A bubble, Galbraith observed, is always supported by the belief that there is something new in the world. The history of past cycles is dismissed as irrelevant.“
That’s it in a nutshell. It is a time-tested part of who we are, and it’s almost like you’re either born with the ability to see that or you’re not. I don’t know why.
I don’t know how much the price will go up, but it going up, even to a million dollars a coin, means little. It will eventually go down and violently so, and some people will be badly hurt. Just people being people.
Assets need to be productive in order to be true investments. Like farmland or businesses. Otherwise, you’re speculating on price appreciation. Look at gold over the last 100 years and overlay its price graph over the Dow Jones during the same period. They’re not even close.
http://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-y...
http://stockcharts.com/freecharts/historical/marketindexes.h...
That’s the difference between speculation and investment.
Counterpoint: Galbraith confidently called the US stock market a "classic bubble" in April, 1999. At that time, the Dow Jones was at 10,494. Today it's at 24,504.
Looking back with 20/20 hindsight, it now looks like Galbraith was wrong.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/business/1999/apr/18/observerbus...
> Assets need to be productive in order to be true investments
Counterpoint: Maybe assets need to be useful to have value. Land, copper, the balance on a Walmart gift card and my World of Warcraft gold don't produce anything, but they're useful, so they have value.
> Counterpoint: Galbraith confidently called the US stock market a "classic bubble" in April, 1999. At that time, the Dow Jones was at 10,494. Today it's at 24,504.
No! Current day valuation versus 1999 valuation has nothing to do with each other. In 1999 the market was over valued and the bubble soon popped.
> > Assets need to be productive in order to be true investments
> Counterpoint: Maybe assets need to be useful to have value. Land, copper, the balance on a Walmart gift card and my World of Warcraft gold don't produce anything, but they're useful, so they have value.
The key difference between an asset and investment is that investments produce returns.
Right, but an asset can go up in price and stay there if demand increases and/or the currency the price is denominated in is losing value over time. Especially true if supply is limited.
I don't expect BTC to stay at $17000 - it could go down or up, and I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if it's currently in a bubble that pops. It might then go to near-$0, or it might proceed to regain those levels and continue even higher over time, depending on how demand evolves against the ultimately fixed supply. I remember $500 for 1 BTC seemed insanely high at the time. $675 must have seemed crazy for gold in 2006, but I don't expect it to return there again despite the intervening ups and downs.
Here's a chart of the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Please identify this bubble popping that you speak of.
After 18 years we can say that Galbraith was objectively wrong.
When assets appear overvalued, sometimes they are, and sometimes people just don't see their potential at the time.
Because the fundamentals of Bitcoin and The Blockchain are complete garbage. Both are solutions in search of problems. Neither solve any real world problems outside of how to conduct shady, illegal business (murder for hire, crypto-ransomware, mail-order bath-salt delivery) and both do a pretty piss-poor job of even that.
This is why bitcoin will ultimately fail. It is a useless product. Full stop.
This is exactly my point.
Why are you so certain?
How can you tell the difference between this and any other technology adoption logistic curve?
People make statements like you do with 100% confidence, and you could very well be right! But where do you get your certainty?
And were you equally certain about the inevitable demise of cryptocurrencies when the market was 1% or 10% of its current size?