News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by ugh on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @05:29AM (#1590967)
I don't think you really believe that god can do anything. Wouldn't a god that can do anything truly be able to do anything, even logically inconsistent things?

You to me seem to believe that god can do a great many things but not anything. Your answer to 5 doesn't seem to be your actual belief.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:51AM (#1591607)
First, I don't believe in God, so this isn't a matter of belief but a matter of definition.

Second, I have no problem with God creating a world where the principle of contradiction doesn't hold. What I have a problem with, is God modifying a realm that depend only on a set of fixed definitions. This is not impossible, this is unthinkable.

Also, we have complete control over such realms. These are just concepts. There is no notion of "can" or "can't" there. Mathematical realms are just self consistent. By definition. So, talking about what God "can" or "can't" do in these realms is meaningless.