Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test...
by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @06:44AM
(#1591080)
You're right, the explanation of the contradiction is poor. The true contradiction is that your definition of sin is arbitrary -- if God simply decides what is "sin" and that definition is in and of itself malleable, what makes an action "sinful?"
Tomorrow I will see if I have my Socrates texts. I think he spoke about this in the Creeto (piety under the Gods).
This is stupid. I said that god COULD change what is considered sinful and that god would WANT to minimize suffering. Being able to do something isn't a contradiction with wanting something else if they never do it. I'm ABLE to kick the cat, but I don't WANT to hurt it - my beliefs about the cat aren't a contradiction.
I never said that such a god would change the definition of sin to make decreasing suffering a sin, just that they would be able to and wouldn't want to. Where is the contradiction?