News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by dkersten on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:13AM (#1590732)
You claimed earlier that any being which it is right to call God must want there to be as little suffering in the world as possible. But you say that God could make it so that everything now considered sinful becomes morally acceptable and everything that is now considered morally good becomes sinful.

This is stupid. I said that god COULD change what is considered sinful and that god would WANT to minimize suffering. Being able to do something isn't a contradiction with wanting something else if they never do it. I'm ABLE to kick the cat, but I don't WANT to hurt it - my beliefs about the cat aren't a contradiction.

I never said that such a god would change the definition of sin to make decreasing suffering a sin, just that they would be able to and wouldn't want to. Where is the contradiction?

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @06:44AM (#1591080)
You're right, the explanation of the contradiction is poor. The true contradiction is that your definition of sin is arbitrary -- if God simply decides what is "sin" and that definition is in and of itself malleable, what makes an action "sinful?"

Tomorrow I will see if I have my Socrates texts. I think he spoke about this in the Creeto (piety under the Gods).

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by dkersten on Friday August 20, 2010 @07:37AM (#1620114)
If god couldn't redefine sin, then god would not be all powerful, which, in my opinion, is a requirement of being considered "god".