Re:In the Middle Ages, the Upper Class Went Nuts for Almond ...
by emodendroket on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @09:30AM
(#15905759)
My judgment is somewhat clouded by the fact that I have no idea what many of the things on this map are, but in general, I get it if we're talking about, like, Prince Edward Island oysters, but I don't think regional distinctions make much sense for preparations. I think it makes more sense to delineate the preparation required to call something by a particular name (so, for instance, if you wanted to really clamp down on Parmesan cheese, I'd prefer specifying the method you have to use over just saying if it's from Parma it's good but if it's from Wisconsin you can't call it that).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:In the Middle Ages, the Upper Class Went Nuts for Almond ...
by mijamo on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @09:49AM
(#15905888)
Both are usually needed. This is because many properties of the final product are determined by the local fauna/flora as well.
In addition there is the whole question of IP for names of cities/regions. I mean if a place makes efforts to ensure that good quality products are made there, it becomes like a brand that needs to be protected.
So for me protecting Parma Ham is just the same as protecting Coca Cola, just that the moral person is the community living in the place instead of a multinational company.
Nothing prevents you from making of copy of Parma Ham and building your brand, just like you can copy Cocal Cola or any other product. Just don't use the name.
Re:In the Middle Ages, the Upper Class Went Nuts for Almond ...
by emodendroket on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:45PM
(#15907656)
I mean, ultimately I don't agree with this perspective. Nobody would maintain that only Burgundians can make Beef Burgundy, or only Ukrainians (what's the demonym here, Kievites?) can do Chicken Kiev, right?