News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by roenxi on Sunday December 10, 2017 @04:32PM (#15893607)
As a society, we have demonstrated a remarkably limited ability to coherently articulate what the problems are.

Now, if you can articulate a clear problem, I might be persuaded that engineers as class will solve it a specific way. But my experience is that once a problem is identified anyone could do it. Identifying the problem is the part that generates friction.

In the one-line example you came up with, you imply:

* Working is good

* Economic productivity is the end goal

* Possibly a link between morality and citizenship

* That 'replacement' based on some unknown process will be legitimate

If I am allowed to assume things like that, every human problem becomes easy and I can engineer it. But a 'landslide' in politics is 60% agreement on a subject - assumptions like this do not fly. I, for example, disagree with at least 2 of those points.

There are no comments on this comment yet.