News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by junkscience2017 on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:46PM (#15892489)
#1 flows from the strange rationalization that regardless of anything else in life, studying humanities for four years in college turns one into a great abstract thinker....while studying engineering for four years permanently transforms you into a robot

amazing that people still believe that an undergrad education either turns you into Napoleon or R2D2

Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by sidlls on Sunday December 10, 2017 @03:14PM (#15893268)
How odd. There is a meme in engineering circles that people who don't study math or science are somehow less able to think and reason. I wasn't aware of the sort of inverse you posit.

My personal experience on this is extremely lopsided: it's rare for me to encounter a non-techie who doesn't fawn embarrassingly at me when I tell them what my academic background is (physics) or gush over how smart and good at math I must be, etc., while on the other hand I hear from engineer peers all the time about how non-techies are dumb, incompetent, play politics, etc.

Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by junkscience2017 on Sunday December 10, 2017 @04:13PM (#15893528)
nowhere did I claim that only engineers were numerate, logical or analytical
Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by barrkel on Sunday December 10, 2017 @04:14PM (#15893539)
The bias is rather that engineering makes you great at building things, but humanities is required to know what to build.

It's just as suspect to me as it probably is to you. Humanities is just as susceptible to building castles in the air as software engineering, flights of intellectual fantasy about how the world ought to be. Difference is, when humanities makes a mistake, you get fascism or communism, rather than crashing code or broken bridges.

Re:Good engineers make terrible leaders by greenhouse_gas on Sunday December 10, 2017 @02:02PM (#15892896)
And that an engineer can't be interested in humanities - there are plenty of engineers who have hobbies outside engineering.