News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by torstenvl on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:44AM (#15886562)
Mensa is not exceptionally smart. It's 2% of all people. [removed a distracting point about social group size.] Most people are likely to know someone who could qualify for Mensa.

Mensa is quite smart, but I wouldn't use the word "exceptional." If you write a method that throws an exception on 2% of all inputs, I think maybe you're doing it wrong. 2% is still too common, in my opinion, to be considered an exception.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by yorwba on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:46AM (#15886576)
You are making quite the assumption there about the number of one's friends and acquaintances.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by torstenvl on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:51AM (#15886615)
True, it's an assumption, but my assumption is rooted in Dunbar's numbers.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ajmurmann on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15886680)
Dunbar's Number is about our cognitive ability to keep social relationships, not about how many social relationships people actually have. The later should be expected to vary widely by society, age, where you live etc. I don't understand what military unit sizes tell you about number of friends and acquaintances someone has.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by chrisseaton on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:08PM (#15886715)
Some argue that a platoon or troop is a natural number of men you can get to know well, and a company or squadron the number you can be well acquainted with.

Not saying that’s true, just explaining.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ajmurmann on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:19PM (#15886774)
That makes a lot of sense, just like Dunbar's Number does. However, at least from my personal, anecdotal experience my number of friends and acquaintances isn't currently capped or was ever capped by my cognitive capability of being well acquainted with them, but rather by not actually meeting that many people and having very little time and energy to get to know the people I meet better. And on top of that things like moving result in weakened or lost relationships.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by dnautics on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:26PM (#15887180)
> my number of friends and acquaintances isn't currently capped or was ever capped by my cognitive capability of being well acquainted with them, but rather by... having very little time and energy to get to know the people I meet better.

What's the difference between "cognitive capacity" and "time and energy"?

I have a near photographic memoy for faces and an exceptional ability to remember details about people's lives; I have to limit the number of friends o have for precisely that reason, my cognitive capacity to care would overshadow just about everything else in life.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ajmurmann on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:26PM (#15892382)
Well the difference is this: If I'm sitting at home every evening because I'm too exhausted from work or come home late every evening and thus have very little social interaction is a very different limiting factor than what caps the number of people in a military unit that I can keep social bounds with. In fact I might be very effective at keeping good working relationships with a large number of coworkers. That doesn't translate at all though to having many friends. At one point in my career I knew everyone in an office of about 100 people by name and had frequently very pleasant conversations with then. Yet I had fewer casual (as opposed to close) friends in the city I lived in than can be counted on one hand.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by nordsieck on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15886681)
You're assuming that IQs are randomly distributed across relationships. They're not. People are assortative in their associations.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by colek42 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:08PM (#15886717)
The assumption that people reading HN are above average intelligence is probably accurate.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by dsacco on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:30PM (#15886848)
It’s easy to believe that, but if you can’t reasonably quantify it based on anything empirical, why bother?

It’s a cognitive blind spot to assume communities you’re a part of have a higher mean intelligence than the general population :)

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by sametmax on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:13PM (#15887098)
I'm part of a lot of communities, and clearly HN is one of the rare where I am, more often than not, answered in comments by people more intelligent than me. So even if I'd consider myself an average Joe, it seems a good sign that HN has quite a lot of intelligent people. At least more than average.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by SubiculumCode on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:05PM (#15887401)
While I cannot be certain that a randomly selected HN participant is above average intelligence, the average and is clearly is at least 1 SD above average, and the median is not 100. The quality of posts, in-depth knowledge expressed, nuanced, fluid, and flexible thinking, makes this a community in which I wish to participate, and this is coming from someone who frequently communicates with academic researchers and intellectuals in his daily life.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by mrfusion on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:18PM (#15887127)
Hi!
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by alexasmyths on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:39PM (#15886900)
"but if you can’t reasonably quantify it based on anything empirical,"

Simply the writing quality, grammar and sentence structure of the comments on HN would easily be enough to prove that HN readers (well, commenters) are above average.

I spend enough time glazing over headlines, stories and comments from other sites out of casual interest and I'll bet any amount of money this is true.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by jansho on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:01PM (#15887373)
Maybe it’s also the culture around here. I’ve seen a few casual lololol comments that get downvoted a lot, so it creates an impression that if you’re going to say something, at least do it stylishly. (Of course value is important too..)

I like HN, but can’t see it as a social space like most forums are. (And yes I like HN for that reason too!)

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by cromulent on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:54PM (#15886995)
Glazing over?
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by alexasmyths on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:54PM (#15888083)
Ha ha ha. Ya. Glancing over. Irony :)
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by bfuller on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:08PM (#15886716)
that's an upper limit but not a lower
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by kurthr on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:14PM (#15887100)
Indeed... there are many more selective: http://miyaguchi.4sigma.org/BloodyHistory/history.html

Some might wonder what relevance this soap-opera-ish tale has to the stated goals of the high-IQ societies. I would argue that in order to understand what these societies are about, one should understand their history, including the very human motivations that drove their foundings.

Although I agree that depending on your circles (college anyone?) 98th %ile isn't much of a stretch. Further, not having a 2% one-sided outlier in your 30-60 person uncorrelated sample set ranges from 45-70%... but you're not likely to know it, and they're not likely to be Mensa members. Wanting to be a member, may be a bigger indicator for the disorders question.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by waster on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:41PM (#15887641)
There are actually specific terms to label intelligence based on the number of standard deviations from the norm (100 IQ). Two to 3 SD's is highly gifted; 4-5 is exceptionally gifted; and 6+ SD's is profoundly gifted. The numbers change depending on what IQ instrument is used, but the terms for those SD brackets remain the same. I forget what Mensa's IQ threshold is and what IQ instruments they accept as measures (I was a Mensa member for a year about 10 years ago, but they took my only available score, a GRE score, as proof), but it's possible that "exceptionally smart" is technically correct, based on SD thresholds.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ben_w on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:52PM (#15888384)
Just to add, by definition 6σ is one in a billion. It isn’t just “profoundly gifted”, but rather “there are seven of you”.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by barry-cotter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:28PM (#15889915)
IQ is a fat tailed distribution. There are way more people in the tails than the test’s definition and morning would suggest.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ben_w on Sunday December 10, 2017 @06:06AM (#15890907)
IQ is defined to be a normal distribution. Intelligence, on the other hand, isn’t.

This is one of the problems with IQ as a measure of intelligence. IQ 150 doesn’t mean doing mental arithmetic faster than IQ 100 by the same margin that IQ 100 beats IQ 50, only that IQ>150 is as rare as IQ<50.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by johnhenry on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:23PM (#15887153)
In this case, the word "exceptionally" may have some connotations associated with it that you've applied, but it really should be treated as your "quite".