In the case of contaminated water, couldn't the insurance company seek sane recourse from the polluters? Usually in cases where contaminated water is a factor in the health of a community, the contamination and perpetrator is known.
As for power lines.. well, there haven't really been any conclusive studies in this area. But you get the point.
Same-environment shouldn't be a factor, as long as the reasons the environment might impact health are/can be known.
I'd argue that nobody should be living somewhere that might have health risks involved (e.g., underground oil spills, toxic ash, a radioactive waste storage facility a block away from the elementary school .... in other words, williamsburg/greenpoint brooklyn).
There was probably some ass-covering going on in the insurance company asked.
Re:Why I'm not hiring
by jessriedel on Monday August 09, 2010 @03:17PM
(#1589034)
> The profit motives of private health care favor denying care, since not paying out money is a good way to make money.
This is an argument against all private insurance (home, auto, etc).
Re:Why I'm not hiring
by infinite8s on Monday August 09, 2010 @04:02PM
(#1589172)
The difference between health insurance and other types is that payouts for health insurance are theoretically unbounded (well, until the patient dies).
Re:Why I'm not hiring
by jessriedel on Monday August 09, 2010 @05:37PM
(#1589500)
Catastrophic health coverage is not particularly expensive. It would be much more reasonable for the government to cover catastrophic costs (say, those in excess of $200,000) and otherwise leave private insurance alone.
Depends on the coverage you agreed on.
I've never heard of homeowners insurance companies refusing to cover people in the same neighborhood. Why is it different?
Would you favor the nationalization of all types of insurance or just medical? Doesn't auto-insurnace have the same evil profit motive?
Re:Why I'm not hiring
by infinite8s on Monday August 09, 2010 @04:01PM
(#1589168)
With homeowner's insurance the upper limit is known (cost of house + possessions). This isn't the case with health insurance - or at least it's in the millions, and nobody could afford the premiums on a group policy where everybody might have correlated health issues.
This is one reason I'm in favor of government health care: The profit motives of private health care favor denying care, since not paying out money is a good way to make money. So you have case where nobody will cover you for arbitrary reasons, or deny you payment due to a "pre-existing condition" or some other nonsense.