This is actually an extremely inefficient and demoralizing environment for those involved. Yeah, it's easy to take over when someone leaves, because they were so hamstrung by the environment that they never built anything interesting. And you're going to be doing a lot of this taking over, because people are always leaving, because they were hamstrung. So this idea that we can't trust individuals to stick around and do a good job, and we have to make sure they never have enough power to do damage when they make a mistake, it's a self fulfilling prophecy. It makes them untrustworthy and drives them away.
It really is about ownership. Programmers who are achieving at a high level move much faster and do much greater things. It's worth letting them make mistakes to retain the best people and get their best work. The only catch is figuring out how to keep them accountable for their decisions. OK, you want to use this new tech or try this new architecture. How do we tie your compensation and career progress to the success of those decisions?
No amount of ownership is going to cover for an otherwise brilliant developer who jumps ship once the project has shipped its MVP. And if that brilliant developer wrote that project in, say, Haskell (because they wanted to learn it), that project is probably doomed from a financial point of view - a quality Haskell developer willing to do maintenance on an existing project will likely cost more than the project is worth in the first place.
The root of this problem does lie in management, but it's a self fulfilling prophecy at this point: employees have taken the lesson to heart. Even companies which do give fantastic benefits are going to still see high turnover, and need to account for that.
That's not what I was talking about. Employees are neither bricks nor cogs. But having said that, if you run any long-term project, you should expect people to come and go, it's part of the game. Thinking that this will not happen in your project is simply negligent.
> This is actually an extremely inefficient and demoralizing environment for those involved.
It doesn't have to be. Working with common conventions and tools doesn't have to be demoralizing. Conventions should be set for a good reason, after an open discussion, and possibly even a vote ("Do you think that it's worth bringing in this library?", "Should we all use the same IDE?"). Also, conventions aren't set in stone, they can change over time.
This gives the team ownership of their project. It makes passing knowledge between team members easier, it makes it easy for team members to help each other when they've run into an issue, not to mention that it makes code reviews and various technical discussions a lot easier.
If Bob is writing using a different language or a set of libraries than the rest of us, who can review Bob's code? Who can help him out when he's stuck on some bug? Who can help him flesh out his design ideas for some feature he's writing?
Without team cohesion, you're creating not a team of developers, but a bunch of individuals who happen to work on related stuff. I don't know about you, but to me that sounds a lot more demoralizing. To me, one of the great benefits of working on a team is that we all get to learn from each other, plus we get to share a common goal. Agreeing to some common conventions seems like a small price to pay for that.
I worked at a place that essentially standardized on Vim. They emphasised pair programming so IDE standardization helped with that. If you already use Vim, sounds great. If not, probably sounds terrible. So what looked like team cohesion was homogeneity. They subtly turned away a lot of people who didn't fit the mold in what should be a minor detail.
I've worked at two companies that basically banned Redis. Having a conversation with an SRE who had a bad experience, trying to convince him it's worth having this tool available, is one of my worst professional memories. Consensus driven technical decisions suck. It's better to give people authority and responsibility. I would have happily admined it myself.
Nobody's going to review Bob's code, not really. If they're not working directly with him on the project and it's doing anything reasonably complex, then they don't have the context to say anything useful beyond catching typos. Things get rewritten every few years anyway.
The bigger problem is that many companies do not reward that, they reward doing it quickly and not asking too many questions.
(Somewhat seriously) are you hiring?
I'd be more inclined to say one of the main roles any manager is facilitation more than anything else. Any manager that "sets convention" is somebody who wants the easy part of technology without the corresponding hard part.
Talking about technical solutions is easy. Implementing it is much harder.
I've come across multiple "technical managers" who were hands on with code greater than x years ago and they always end up talking out of their arse. And that's not to mention the numerous wrong choices they've committed to/spoke about at a high level meeting with zero notion.
Common ownership does not end up with a random patchwork of technologies. Teams make collective decisions on them.
I might like to write CGI programs in Prolog with a MarkLogic db, I'm not going to unilaterally decide to write my bit of a team application like that when everyone else writes WSGI Python applications with Postgres.
If you focus only on deliverables and deadlines, you'll end up with developers using a mix of different approaches, libraries and even languages. It hurts team cohesion and makes the logistics of project management much harder since Joe can't take over Tom's code now that Tom has the flu.
As I see it, one of the main tasks of a technical manager is to set conventions so everyone would feel at least semi-comfortable with everyone else's code. That's not micro-management, that's management.