News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:04AM (#15884961)
This is an extremely biased piece of journalism that almost anyone on the ground in the Philippines would disagree with. Very dishonest and should not be trusted at face value.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Lazare on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:33AM (#15885025)
This is a story about people spreading false, content-free things on social media to discredit political opponents. In that context, your comment raises more questions than it answers.

In addition, the piece makes a large number of factual assertions that could be easily verified. Are journalists being targeted for harassment? Are government-linked bloggers advocating for the arrest of journalists? A moment's googling suggests the answer is "yes". And of course Duterte's death squads are well known.

Edit: Also, I don't think a glib accusation of bias helps much here. Yes, no doubt there's two (or more) sides to this story, but even if true, that amounts to nothing more than a tu quoque at best, and a "they deserved it" at worst.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by sago on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:07AM (#15884970)
For those of us on the other side of the world, Would you be willing to give a quick summary of the biases you see in the piece, a taster of your experience of the reality on the ground?
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:00AM (#15885094)
The article makes it sound like it's fake accounts who are against some in the media, but it's really the entire population.

The article calls out fake profile pictures on facebook as some indication of an artificial message. This is wrong - many people on facebook use fake profile pictures. I use a fake profile picture myself, although my account is genuine. Probably a third of your facebook friend list uses fake profile pictures - go check for yourself. The article also says they have collected a database of facebook accounts that post pro-Duterte messages as if this is somehow an indictment. With Duterte having an 80%+ approval rating across 100mil people population, many of whom have Facebook accounts, do you think a database of 2mil posters is somehow unexpected or fake?

From my time in the Philippines, everyone on the street supports Duterte because he's given them a sense of safety again. For many in western countries, this kind of feeling is unknown because you've likely never walked the streets expecting to be killed at any moment - you have working police and institutions that keep you safe. For many years, the Philippines did not have this, and they see Duterte as having helped make them safe. This breeds an almost fanatical devotion for obvious reasons, and most Phillipinos on social media will defend him with ferocity. The article tries to associate this as something bad and fake. But it's not, it's real and genuine. You can open up Twitter right now and go to Trump's feed and you will see people who hate him and many who wish violence on him. That doesn't mean those people are fake - and the people supporting Duterte aren't fake either.

Here's a quick video on how regular people in the Philippines feel about articles like this one: https://youtu.be/siAjsu0ZmKE?t=429

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Lazare on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:39AM (#15885200)
The issue with fake accounts is they can help skew popular opinion. It's not a defence to say "yeah, there's fake accounts, but popular opinion agrees with them". All that means is they (might be) working.

> The article calls out fake profile pictures on facebook as some indication of an artificial message.

It did not; it called out fake profiles. Nowhere in the article did it suggest that a fake profile picture was itself evidence of a fake profile.

> The article also says they have collected a database of facebook accounts that post pro-Duterte messages as if this is somehow an indictment.

It's a database of (mostly real) accounts that post messages that originate with fake accounts; it's a way of measuring the scale of the problem. If millions of real accounts echo these fake messages, it does't mean that there isn't a problem, it means the problem is really big.

> For many in western countries, this kind of feeling is unknown because you've likely never walked the streets expecting to be killed at any moment - you have working police and institutions that keep you safe.

The homicide rate in the Philippines isn't that high; it's comparable to where the US was 20 years ago. That's obviously not ideal, but there are countries where when expecting death when you walk down the street is reasonable. Honduras has a murder rate of 90 per 100k people; El Salvador is 70 per 100k people. The Philippines is 9 per 100k.

> The article tries to associate this as something bad and fake. But it's not, it's real and genuine.

You're talking about a "sense of safety" and "feelings", and then discounting claims of fake stories as if those stories couldn't possibly influence these feelings. Nobody is claiming that Duterte isn't popular; we're discussing why he's popular. Maybe he's popular because of stories spread by fake Facebook accounts that made people feel safer, even though the fundamentals haven't changed?

Plus, if you look at the actual numbers, in Duterte's first year in office, according the the Philippine National Police, murders actually increased by 22.75%.

> everyone on the street supports Duterte because he's given them a sense of safety again

You don't see any issues here?

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:00AM (#15885254)
The article gives zero proof of any kind of fake accounts aside from fake profile pictures, and calls Facebook out for not removing the accounts, even thought Facebook says they have removed the fake ones. So clearly Facebook does not feel that those particular accounts are fake either.

Calling someone you don't like a "fake account" (as someone has already hinted about me in this very comment section!), does not suddenly turn it into a fake account. It's a real account until you provide absolute proof - especially when the supposed fake account has the same opinion as 80mil+ people in a country. Sorry.

The rest of your argument hinges on the idea that 80mil people are terribly stupid and can't tell fake accounts from real accounts - even though they live in the country - and have fallen for a ruse. While you, in your great wisdom - who has probably never been in the Philippines? - know them all to be fake without any evidence. That's a fairly poor argument in my opinion.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by LV-426 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:33AM (#15885353)
> Calling someone you don't like a "fake account" (as someone has already hinted about me in this very comment section!)

I don't know where someone hinted that you're a fake account, but you are certainly disingenuously passing yourself off as some kind of authority on what ordinary Filipinos think, when you don't even live in the Philippines, but a country thousands of miles away.

This explains why your only evidence of "the entire population" favouring Duterte is a Youtube of people who like Duterte saying they like Duterte, and what some people allegedly told you when you visited the country.

> even though they live in the country [...] who has probably never been in the Philippines?

And why are you even getting so worked up and fanatical about this? Because you spent two weeks in Boracay? It's not your country - you live in South Africa - so why are you acting otherwise?

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by e19293001 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:56AM (#15885797)
> Because you spent two weeks in Boracay? It's not your country

Hey! I don't know him. I live in the Philippines and I believe in what he said.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:32AM (#15885526)
I spent a number of months there talking to people while doing remote work. It's a great place to visit - highly recommend it to anyone!

As for why I'm posting: all it takes for evil to win is for good men to stay silent.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by foodislove on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:05AM (#15885627)
So a foreigner who talks to some people while doing remote work is presenting himself as an authority on the views of people of said country. Well then, I've visited Cancun on a number of occasions. I can say for a fact, that all Mexicans drink Corona beer.

What is baffling is how someone who has no idea what they are talking about, does nothing but make Trump like complaints about bias and how "everyone" likes the dictator etc etc. Troll

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Lazare on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:05AM (#15885269)
As we've learned to our sorrow people in first world countries (eg, Americans, Germans, etc.) can't reliably detect fake accounts or fake news stories. Why should Filipinos be uniquely able to do so?
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:18AM (#15885312)
I don't believe that is true. You want it to be true, and so you've fallen for it. The only kind of fake news stories anybody falls for are fake news stories that support their own biases. Such as this article, but that goes without saying.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by veidr on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:01AM (#15885619)
You are utterly wrong about that, and it is easily proven. (People not only believe the fake news stories, some of them even arm themselves and storm pizza parlors to rescue the innocent children Hillary Clinton is trafficking as sex slaves, or refuse to vaccinate their kids and thereby put their own children and others at risk, etc etc etc etc etc).

But it's interesting you are getting so worked up defending this idea — why is that? What cognitive bruise are you protecting?

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by yorwba on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:01AM (#15885443)
> The only kind of fake news stories anybody falls for are fake news stories that support their own biases.

I'd rather say that people only fall for fake news stories that don't run counter to their own biases. I.e. when someone is completely ignorant about a topic, and the first story they read about it is fake news, they might believe it.

In any case, you seem to be agreeing that people fall for fake news that supports their own biases, hence:

>> people in first world countries (eg, Americans, Germans, etc.) can't reliably detect fake accounts or fake news stories.

They can reliably detect whether something does or does not agree with their preexisting knowledge/biases, but that doesn't always help with detecting fake accounts or fake news.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by RyanZAG on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:30AM (#15885520)
The article itself provides no proof that the people they are calling fake are indeed fake. That counts as being deliberately malicious in my book, but I'd think it would count as being 'biased' in anybody's book. That's all I wanted to bring to people's attention. Often just pointing it out to people is enough to help sway them away from making a mistake, and trusting this article as being on the level would be a terrible mistake for anyone to make.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by anon1385 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:20AM (#15885318)
>The rest of your argument hinges on the idea that 80mil people are terribly stupid

No more stupid than 60m people in Germany or 40m people in Italy or 10m people in Chile or 4m people in Haiti or 30m people in the Philippines or 7m people in Zimbabwe or 20m people in Venezuela etc.

It doesn't require a 'stupid' population to believe the propaganda of murderous regimes; it's something any group of people is susceptible to, as we have seen time and again at great cost.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Joe-Z on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:43AM (#15885389)
Thank you for the insight. It seems to me people in the western world/media just can't accept that leaders in other countries can genuinely have high approvals in the population despite behaving dictatorial and using violence (I'm also thinking of people like Putin and Erdogan here).

This is something that we've (we as in western europeans) also had our fair share of and thought it over and done with. The reality seems to be though that time and again crises arise which enable violent/dictatorial leaders to rise to power.

I don't try to defend anything Duterte's doing here. In fact I don't really know too much about what he's done, other than the horrendous 'everbody's free to kill drug dealers' policy. I just don't like that so many news outlets seem to be fixated on discrediting genuine approval and followings as all just being 'fake news'.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Joe-Z on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:54AM (#15886038)
Please people, tell me what is wrong with this comment! Tear me up, show me my errors, make me understand, but don't just downvote me and leave me in the dark.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by Micoloth on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:12PM (#15887825)
Man.. Nobody has ever said Duerte isn't supported by the population. All dictators have some kind of support, otherwise they could never govern.

People is saying two things. First we (as western world) know dictatorship is bad, because exactly how you said, we've been there. Expecially Europe. US has actually never tried it. But we actually know what happens.

Second, we also know that to get to power dictators always have to use extremely violent or aggressive techniques. Maybe by condemning these we could prevent dictatorships and all the crap that follows altogheter.

Besides, it's instead entirely possible to me that this is an unskippable step in a country's history, and people have to go through that phase and try it on their skin, so whatever.

The point of the artcle was more about the role of Facebook into this anyway.

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by mythrwy on Saturday December 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15886891)
What is wrong with that comment is very simple.

It suggests the unthinkable possibility that a leader, whom the downvoter doesn't care for, may actually be popular with others. And that just can't be right, it has to be all propaganda and fake news causing this mistaken popularity. Similar to "Russians stole the election!" in the US. It's a failure to comprehend or accept people have different backgrounds, beliefs and values and a certainty that preference and political opinion are objective truth.

Because you suggested many people may in fact possibly support Duarte, you threaten the illusion which is tantamount to supporting Duarte yourself in the mind of the downvoter. It really is a shockingly form of mental myopia from otherwise intelligent people and renders them unable to accurately predict and understand large chunks of the world (like last election in US).

Whether it's politics, religion, unrealistic business goals or unrealistic career goals ("I'm going to be a famous rap artist or else play in the NBA!") I think there is simply no way to get hated on faster than attempting to ground an illusion with reality. You become perceived as part of the problem when you do that. (Still needs to be done though IMOP).

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by johnhenry on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:18AM (#15884990)
Agreed, I would love to hear more perspectives.
Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by ISL on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:26AM (#15885013)
Citation needed.

It is an opinionated piece, to be sure, but Bloomberg is generally relatively centrist and well-sourced.

Care to elaborate or point us to countervailing sources?

Re:How Duterte Turned Facebook into a Weapon, with Help from... by hacker-gene on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:40AM (#15885965)
Well, yes it can be pointed out as bias like any other news out there but "Very dishonest ..."?

As other media organization have reported, in case you're interested: https://newrepublic.com/article/138952/rodrigo-dutertes-army... http://comprop.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/89/2017...