Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by jackhack on Saturday December 09, 2017 @10:12AM
(#15886106)
>> What you find is that it's the 3% of assholes who make a mess for everyone else.
You have just neatly summarized all of the recorded history of humanity.
Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by icc97 on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:03AM
(#15885825)
If you look across Europe where most nations have had as much time as the other to learn the rules (which is now about 100 years), there are still big differences.
Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by mmjaa on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:05AM
(#15885834)
Cue the difference between German, Austrian, and Hungarian drivers.
Germans: can be very aggressive at times. Austrians, only if you're in the wrong lane. Hungarians: fear for your life if you ever try to overtake someone ..
Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by everdev on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:32AM
(#15886490)
Some of this is propagation of cultural myths/stereotypes. In a country of millions of people there will be millions of people that don't conform to these blanket statements.
In the US, states and cities have their own driving stereotypes that don't fit neatly into an easily summarized national driving style.
Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by mmjaa on Thursday December 14, 2017 @12:57PM
(#15924572)
In my case, direct experience with the driving conditions of all three countries, over a decade. ;P
Re:‘Shared Space’ Design: Road Signs Suck. What If We Got Ri...
by chiph on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:50AM
(#15886599)
serpentza has a video on driving in China:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUfsB2siCOI
Skip to about 9:00
In Thailand people follow the rules a bit more, but they drive recklessly at insane speeds. If you're a teenager, it's not cool to use headlights at night and the first thing you do is remove your mirrors, which no one uses anyway....
But if you go over the border into Laos there are no rules there either, but traffic is completely different from Thailand or Cambodia. People drive slowly, patiently and politely. Lao drivers even put the Japanese to shame and that's a pretty high bar. Laos is a very laid back place. It's too much effort for most people to not do otherwise.
Over the last twenty years I've seen things changing in both mainland China and in Thailand. People are slowly internalizing the rules of the road and following them more with each new generation. You stay in your lane, and your side of the road. You don't run stop signs. You wait for the traffic light to chain to green (or blue in Japan) before you cross a road.
What it comes down to is that rules of the road and road behavior is a collective body of knowledge that takes time to develop in a society. Once that knowledge has been internalized and becomes the cultural norm, then getting rid of traffic signs can work. But there is a learning curve to master that body of knowledge and a correspondingly greater responsibility that goes with it.