Re:Mozilla’s revenue increased significantly in 2016
by nialv7 on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:01AM
(#15890018)
There's another firefox prompt which also annoys me.
Firefox sometimes asks me if I want to do a factory reset, clear all my settings and add-ons, "to make the browser faster".
I believe most users will find this question absurd. And Mozilla give it a pretty baity name, too. "Refresh Firefox". What if someone clicks Yes by mistake?
Re:Mozilla’s revenue increased significantly in 2016
by adsche on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:05AM
(#15884964)
Re 3.: I think that's a terrible promtp. The prompt says, my settings might be outdated and I should switch back to Google as a search engine. What's the reasoning here? Why is implied that the settings are outdated if I use a custom search engine? No other settings are checked/affected by this prompt, so why frame it as a settings issue at all?
Re 4.: Why silently, why not a prompt here?
Re:Mozilla’s revenue increased significantly in 2016
by NiceGuy_Ty on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:04PM
(#15888432)
Using an HTTP based search engine should be explicitly opt-in, imo. Moving it to https by default seems like the right choice for non-technical users.
The decision tree is roughly:
1. If the custom engine is one of our default options, keep it.
2. If the custom engine was set by an add-on, keep it.
3. If the custom engine uses HTTPS, prompt the user to actively choose by opening about:searchreset, and do not prompt again after the user has made a choice.
4. If the custom engine uses insecure HTTP, silently reset to the default.
You can open about:searchreset yourself to see what the prompt looks like.
Code at https://dxr.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/rev/a928be5dacc3b544...