Not really. The OECD average is 36%, Americans pay 28% and no western European states pay less. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu... In nominal terms the US may be higher, but I don't really see that that proves anything. The main problem is of course that so much has to be paid for by the individual in the US that is efficiently taken care of by the state in Europe, so comparing tax rates misses a big part of the issue.
> Not really. The OECD average is 36%, Americans pay 28% and no western European states pay less.
Yes really. American's pay 28% on a larger number, so the amount of money per person is basically the same.
BTW - you're ignoring corporate taxes, which are a significant fraction of revenues. They don't actually change the equivalence but they do increase the "revenues per person-year" number.
> nominal terms the US may be higher, but I don't really see that that proves anything.
Actually, it does.
> The main problem is of course that so much has to be paid for by the individual in the US that is efficiently taken care of by the state in Europe, so comparing tax rates misses a big part of the issue.
I'm not comparing tax rates. I'm comparing tax revenues per person.
You're pointing out that western Europeans get more for the same amount of money.
Combining those two facts tells us that a tax dollar goes further in western Europe than it does in the US.
If the US govt wants to provide the same benefits, it either needs more money per person than European govts or it needs to take the relevant amount of money from its other expenditures.
Don't you mean `regressive' then?
Not at all. A "progressive" tax system defined as one where those with more money pay a (progressively) larger fraction of said money. Since SS also has direct benefits, you look at the sum.
Actually, it doesn't. US tax revenue per-person is pretty much in the middle of western Europe.
Things look different because US GDP/person is higher and poor workers only pay for their retirement. (SS payouts are fairly progressive, so it's a good deal for the poor and sucks for those near the cap. The cap exists because we don't want rich people to care about SS and we don't want to pay $400k/year to Ross Perot. If you want to remove the cap, please tell us how you're going to deal with rich people caring about SS, which they will if benefits are capped, or if you're going to uncap the benefits as well.)