And the answer is yes if and only if the business is lawful.
In other words, you never need the blockchain, unless you can't use the power of the law to enforce your contracts. Every. Single. Other. supposed use-case of the blockchain could be done by using a regular database and real-world contracts. Yes, even money (cf PayPal, Western Union, etc...).
But if you're doing something illegal, then you can't have contracts and the threat of a lawsuit to enforce them. This where the blockchain and Bitcoin in particular becomes useful.
Sure you don't "need" the blockchain to accomplish legacy X (LX), but what if blockchain X (BX) is 90% cheaper than LX (anything that avoids going to court will lead to massive cost savings)? A lot of the "known" use cases for blockchain tech involve squeezing out inefficiencies from the status quo. As with any new technology there could be additional applications unknown at this time unlocked as well.
Of coure, it could turn into something illegal at some later point in time (like owning gold did).
Also the banks love blockchain technology because they don't like having to trust each other.
That was an easy pass.
I ultimately turned it down because I didn't think this magical internet points fad was going to work out. But I regret it now. Yes, of course the business tanked sleazily, but had I allowed myself to educate myself and buy in (in both meanings of the phrase) to the BTC craze back when it had a two-digit price point… I could be a kajillionaire.
For the vast majority of use cases, the answer to that question is 'yes'. I'd say recognizing this and avoiding the places using blockchain just because it's trendy should be a priority.
1. The false disintermediation; when really they want to put themselves as the intermediary
2. This is so much better than what exists, we just need everyone to adopt it at once, in order to get the network effect that makes adopting it in the first place worthwhile.
3. We just need to solve this one problem to unlock the potential (insert HARD economic problem, that world has been failing to solve for last 30 years).
4. Just being bunch of nonsense, but who cares, with so much blind speculation we might come our rich as long as we scarper before the bubble bursts.
5. We just need these 3 miracles for success
6. Our solution is basically just the same as what exists, however we are really excited because we will implement it with blockchain!
Sounds like I hate the tech, I don't, just hate the bullshiters.
This is my exact feeling in regards to blockchain. Bitcoin is fucking stupid, but blockchain does have uses - unfortunately there are a lot of bullshitters out there.
You should have the skill to always be asking:
1. Could this business be built without blockchain as a technology? (suitability of the technology for the use case)
2. Could this business succeed without blockchain as a feature? (hype filter)
Then beyond that, you need tremendous CS fundamentals, as well as pretty deep understanding of cryptography, distributed computing, networking, databases, application security, network security, information security.
You should also ask why you want to work at a blockchain startup.