News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by nategri on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @05:52PM (#15865901)
Also: Cross products.
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by ajkjk on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @07:59PM (#15866665)
I'm sure it's out there somewhere, but it would be an appropriate corollary to the OP if there was a "Down with Cross Products", which argues that multivectors and wedge products should be taught instead of cross products in multivariable calculus. Then, determinants are "the wedge product of N linearly independent vectors", and cross products are "the wedge product of 2 vectors in 3 dimensions", which gives a bivector and trivially encodes their pseudovector properties.

(Also, surface normals in integrals are bivectors, the 'i' of complex analysis is the bivector resulting from wedge product x^y, and e^(i theta) is the exponential map applied to the i operator, and (del wedge vector-function f) is the (bivector-valued) curl while (del wedge bivector-function g) is the (scalar valued) divergence (and that's why del(del(f)) = 0).)

(But differential forms should probably be omitted in a first course, because they get hairy quickly and are hard to wrap one's head around. It's enough to know that dxdy in integrals is actually dx^dy, and therefore the Jacobian appears when changing variables because of the factor that appears from dx'^dy' = dx'(x,y)^dy'(x,y).)

Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by zodiac on Thursday December 07, 2017 @03:45AM (#15868603)
Which books would you recommend to learn this wedge product / differential forms approach to linear algebra and complex numbers?
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by selimthegrim on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:37AM (#15869501)
Doesn't Spivak get into them?
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by wolfgke on Thursday December 07, 2017 @09:08AM (#15870036)
Michael Spivak has written multiple books. Which one do you mean?
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by tgb on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:51AM (#15871067)
Calculus on Manifolds. I'd recommend Hubbard and Hubbard over that as it's a little easier read with the same material.
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by wolfgke on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:25PM (#15872586)
> I'd recommend Hubbard and Hubbard over that as it's a little easier read with the same material.

John Hamal Hubbard, Barbara Burke Hubbard - Vector Calculus, Linear Algebra and Differential Forms: A Unified Approach

Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by marcelluspye on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @06:47PM (#15866224)
Based on this article, I would venture to guess that Axler is also not a fan of the cross product, though, so he wouldn't feel that much is lost. Cross products are practically a vector-calculus hack that lack generality and risk obscuring intuition at the mathematical level.
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by Koshkin on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @10:49PM (#15867477)
One problem with cross product, it only exists in three dimensions.
Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by wolfgke on Thursday December 07, 2017 @09:05AM (#15870016)
No, it exists in dimension 3 and 7:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven-dimensional_cross_produc...

EDIT: Nore precisely: A common way to axiomatize the cross product yields a cross products exactly in dimension 3 and 7.

Re:Down with Determinants (1995) by sixo on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:02PM (#15872938)
A wedge product exists in all dimensions but only in 3 & 7 is it identifiable with a unique vector.