News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:CIA Software Developer Goes Open Source, Instead by tptacek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @04:51PM (#1586131)
Again: you're right. I'm sure the policy as implemented is both counterproductive and utterly ineffective.

Having said that: just because you can inspect the source code doesn't mean it's safe to run. I don't believe for 1 millisecond that an entire industry of "security-conscious American programmers" would be effective at assuring the Linux IPv6 stack --- not without an actual overt program to arrange for that to happen.

The top vulnerability researchers routinely find game-over flaws in open source code long after the code hits the release branch, and often long after the code has been vetted several times over by other vulnerability researchers.

If my goal was to mess with the US by backdooring critical infrastructure software, I'd almost certainly not do that by inserting code like "look for secret passphrase at offset X from IPv6 extension header Y". Instead, I'd introduce extremely subtle bugs, perhaps depending object lifecycles and concurrency, and I'd make sure they were planted in changesets that improved code quality overall and/or added valuable capabilities to the code.

Re:CIA Software Developer Goes Open Source, Instead by euroclydon on Sunday August 08, 2010 @09:14PM (#1586664)
That has the making of a good novel. Some researcher notices this subtle bug, but rather than blow the whistle overtly, works with the NSA and project gatekeeper to allow the bug through, but with some way to track who might try to take advantage of it. Global tech thriller ensues...
Re:CIA Software Developer Goes Open Source, Instead by aswanson on Sunday August 08, 2010 @05:27PM (#1586202)
I'd introduce extemely subtle bugs...

You sinister bastard. ;) Nuff said, point taken.